Quote from tplast:
I think I solved the mystery. And there's a big gotcha !
This is what it looks like on OV with no slippage. The drop on the right is correct. The reason is that the DEC EW options are based on the march futures contract. When all the options go deep on the money, they'll go for close to their intrinsic value. But the march contract will be higher by about 10 points, which will be reflected on the december options when DITM.
[EDIT] With the ES december contract at 1440. The OCT EW will go for 54, the NOV EW will go for 55 and the DEC EW will go for 69 !