Hey all, you guys were busy as I was out the past two days lol.
Let me catch up on all the comments.
As fro SPX v. XEO, whether you look at number of strikes or % OTM, the SPX gives your more choices and flexibility than the XEO so I still perfer to do credit spreads on the SPX.
Options on futures, the jury is still out for me. Like many of you, since I use OX and ToS I do not have access to them so any review of them is academic since I do not have access to trade them. That should change in a few months if I move some money into an option prop shop where I will have access to them. However I still feel their value comes in as hedging vehicles potentially.
Taxes, I think if you list each leg separately or list it as each spread, you should come out with the same net gain or net loss which is taxable. I create a spreadsheet of the spreads and attach it with my taxes to the appropriate Schedule and simply list the net gains taxable as short-term gains or whereever my accountant puts it (I am happy to let him handle the tax knowledge and stick with trading and JA) and it seems to work fine. The answer is the same so I doubt it would make the IRS ask me to do it over as legs. But you have to talk with your accountant.
If you use OptionsXpress, the account summary is already broken out in legs and has the totals. Simply dump that into a spread sheet and viola.... you are finished in 10 minutes

. One great thign about OX and tax time. Makes it a breeze to dump that into a spreadsheet.