SpreadProfessor Clients - Thanks !
- Thread starter bone
- Start date
Bone - Are you a profitable trader or you just a salesman that sales education ?
Hey Galvin. If you offer a profitable trader like lescor, szeven or Dustin money for mentorship, they will refuse. All three traders that I've mentioned have posted in the p&l thread extensively.
I don't know these guys, nor do I really care-- but one must ask themselves why these "profitable" traders post their P&L extensively in a public forum? Unless they are selling something, there is absolutely zero good that can come from it and massive bad stuff like the IRS etc-- one of the members here already had a run in with the feds due to posting P&L here. Seriously, what's the upside to a profitable trader???
Bone is a legitimate trader and vendor so he has a reason for posting--- the others, I can't think of one.
I suspect the same upside as PTJ gets from his Robin Hood Foundation. Altruism may be a concept alien to you, thankfully some people are different.
Are you saying that vendor gets no benefit from broadcasting his success? If any vendor posted verifiable p/l on a daily basis, they would be inundated with requests to "Shut up and take my money!" Tax issues can befall any trader regardless of their public forum activity.
Lescor and others have repeatedly stated their reasons for posting in the p/l forum. They range from accountability to a form of trader philanthropy. But we all have to remember that bone isn't selling a turn key system. It is an intro to spread trading course with no guarantee of profitability. And as always, the onus is on the trader to succeed...
That's a ridiculous correlation. PTJ helping others directly with real money is the same thing as someone posting P&L in a public forum full of aliases? Altruism DOES NOT EXIST IN THE JUNGLE OF THE MARKET. It is a byproduct of success-- you do not see PTJ talking about his strategies or methods EVER-- why do the folks here??
Last edited:
It probably escapes your attention but more than a few run journals to help others, Convexx for example. I took a quick look at Lescor's last journal and he was quite free in answering questions without revealing anything that would compromise his trading. People were grateful and expressed that. Helping people with action is no less valuable than throwing money at causes. Pity you can't appreciate that.
Edited your post again. Well let me address what you added.
Just because you can't trade competently and thus can't help people doesn't mean that others are similarly useless.
You are truly naive.