Quote from goldenarm:
I hope the NYSE never becomes like an ECN. The stock moves will become super erratic like the Nascrap! Just hope the SEC makes sure that the Specialists perform their jobs correctly!
yeah, seriously. the fact is, since oct 02, they've gotten truly out of control, and in an auction market, they have no business scalping opposing orders that they see at the same time. they're morons to do something like this; in the current environment they're getting scrutinized like crazy anyway, so if they want to trade differently, they should change the exchange rules instead of clearly breaking them and making the world think they're a bunch of thieves (although they are).
the NYSE is simply a better marketplace than nasdaq for regulation. everything goes thru one place, thus it is easier to scrutinize. nasdaq is far more frustrating to trade if you are bothered easily by manipulation.
personally my livelihood depends largely on the NYSE system. although i think that the crackdown on specialists is needed (they're probably taking out .02-.03 per share by not pairing orders properly -- this money should be going into our pockets, not theirs), i really hope that the NYSE model does not change. if it is in fact a good idea to have an ECN market for listed stocks, then why aren't there firms using an ECN business model for listed stocks?? i think that most people realize that the NYSE is a superior system than nasdaq.
yes, there are definitely problems with the NYSE, especially since 10/02, but hopefully what happened yesterday will be the start of a bigger crackdown on the bullshit that's become all too common since 10/02. it would be clearly better if there was less bullshit, less screwing the flow, and less backing away from a posted market, freezing the book, or not updating the quote. i think if that stuff can be eliminated, then the old NYSE will come back and more people will trade it and there will be far more liquidity. right now the lack of liquidity and extreme slippage is really the problem, and all the bullshit routines that the specs pull like i mentioned above has alot to do with the poor liquidity and slippage.
just my .02