Quote from Ghost of Cutten:
So far I've only used gold itself, not any of the stocks. I just feel it's a more pure play, and there's no risk of underperforming the bull run by bad stock selection, corporate mismanagement etc.
However, in the later stages of a bull market, I would expect the miners to start outperforming, so at some point I will probably get into them. If you have any recommendations, I'm all ears.
Basically you have 4 types of gold miners.
- The large caps (Anglogold, Barrick, Newmont).
Offers the smallest leverage on gold but on the other hand the most protection should spot gold turn sour in comparison with the other types mentioned next.
- The producing smaller miners. Think of AUY, CDE, HL, IAG,
Move less in concert then their larger peers so the risk is higher but the reward could be equally higher as well.
- The exploration miners.
Novagold, Gabriel resources,...
They aren't really mining any gold right now but could do so in the near or far away future. Profits could be gigantic (their price has basically already anticipated in most cases on actual mining to take place with high gold prices still around which obviously adds to the risk.)
-Avion gold, orko silver,...
The exploration miners with little to no proven reserves yet or other big obstacles.
Don't really care about these. The risk is way to high imo.
- You also have the ETF's. GDX and GDXJ. They offer a nice view on what miners should be legit and offer the safety of an index tracker which always outperforms owning individual stocks in a bear market.
I'm too dumb to read a balance sheet so in deciding which mine to buy I went for reaction to spot (I want my mines to move in trend with gold and not shoot down 20% when gold is up), institutional ownership (If Soros buys GBG or NG there should be some gold in the ground) and relative underperformance vs it's peers.
Myself only have exposure to type 2 and 3 of which both positions are hedged being USD denominated (I'm european) and with physical gold (in 2008 gold dropped 30% yet the miners dropped 60% to 95%).
To each his own in deciding which way to go that suits his situation best.
If one were to ask me which mine I would buy now if I had to chose one would be GBG, who are in the process of exploration mine to producing one but one should ofcourse do his own due dilligence on the matter I am sure my reasoning behind my stockpicking is rather unconventional and not suited to all.
Cheers.