Something very simplistic

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally posted by inandlong
Okay I have the ES as a SAR B/E for the 1154 trade. Any discrepancies there?
More...

I have it as a double-whammy - L 805.50 (shoulda been 805.75 though, but same end results) and NQ too, L 827.50.


Stop wishing us luck! :D
 
Au contraire Monsieurs Db et Quah. J'ai NQ opening tick at 11:54 to be 826.50! This gives a long winner with the 1158 low of 824 and the subsequent run to 831 later.

This gets back to the discussion of it all working out in the long run.

Zorak, do you have the same data as I do?



ooooo, look at that, ELITE Member. Wow, I wouldn't have wanted to share it on any other thread. Sniff, sniff.
 
Originally posted by inandlong
Au contraire Monsieurs Db et Quah. J'ai NQ opening tick at 11:54 to be 826.50! This gives a long winner with the 1158 low of 824 and the subsequent run to 831 later.

This gets back to the discussion of it all working out in the long run.

Zorak, do you have the same data as I do?



ooooo, look at that, ELITE Member. Wow, I wouldn't have wanted to share it on any other thread. Sniff, sniff.
More...

Wow. Mine says 826.50 too - lol - have no idea what I was looking at to see 827.50 - guess I should increase the font size. :(
 
Originally posted by inandlong
Au contraire Monsieurs Db et Quah. J'ai NQ opening tick at 11:54 to be 826.50! This gives a long winner with the 1158 low of 824 and the subsequent run to 831 later.
More...

Actually, I was referring to the 1059 trade. I show the 1154 trade as a successful long, both NQ.

--Db
 
Originally posted by dbphoenix


Actually, I was referring to the 1059 trade. I show the 1154 trade as a successful long, both NQ.

--Db
More...

I adjusted the workbook for the proper entry (noted accordingly). Are we all in general agreement abouthe 10:59 and 11:54 trades now?
 
Originally posted by inandlong
Au contraire Monsieurs Db et Quah. J'ai NQ opening tick at 11:54 to be 826.50! This gives a long winner with the 1158 low of 824 and the subsequent run to 831 later.

This gets back to the discussion of it all working out in the long run.

Zorak, do you have the same data as I do?
More...

Yep, same on both ES and NQ. Nice to see Quah makes a
mistake every once in awhile, I was starting to think I had
the market cornered!

Attached is my final spreadsheet, for the time being...the last
loss dropped me below margin, so I'm toast for a few
days at least. In my attempt to exactly replicate Q, I'm
considering dumping QCharts and getting esignal+ensign...and
in fact I most likely will before I begin again.

(Ya, I know, in theory the minor differences will even out...but
I have not had a single one go in my favor yet, so why not
just follow him exactly?)

zorak
 

Attachments

Just a thought, I think that Quah's was really what he said and ours was really what we said. So... just for a bright thought, today's NQ trade did work to your advantage. I can't blame you for changing though.

Have a great weekend.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top