Social Security

Quote from thecalip:

The government does not need our tax money. They have the printing press, they can just print what they need.

The only reason to have tax is keep the middle class, aka the working class working. The rich does not need to work. The poor does not want to work. The unemployed wants to work but cannot find work. The middle class is support both group with the tax they paid. Oh yea, the middle class also support the too big too failed and the unions.

Get rich or spend all u have and be poor! The American system screws folks in the middle.
 
Quote from hippie:

Get rich or spend all u have and be poor! The American system screws folks in the middle.

Pssshh...you obviously have never been out of the United States if you think that. At least 80%(probably more) of the world would trade places with a middle class american. If you think middle Americans get screwed, go check out the factories in India or china. Then you will see what screwed really is working 16 hour days for 62 cents per hour. THATS screwed.

Everyone in the United States lives like a king compared to most of the rest of the world. Even our homeless can make 100 bucks per day begging.
 
Quote from tommintj:

"Social security is not a Ponzi scheme. It is a well-planned and well-administered defined benefit plan. There really is a Social Security trust fund and it is 100% invested in securities issued by the U.S. government."

Securities issued by the US government represent future taxes. There are no "assets". Social security taxes are used to pay current recepients and spending on other government "projects".
This meets the defination of a Ponzi scheme.

The money paid into social security is borrowed by the federal government and used for all manner of things. It is owed to the trust fund and must be paid back with interest.. Social Security is a defined benefit retirement plan and has nothing whatsoever to do with Ponzi schemes which are fraudulent.

We can agree that the government spends money in ways we don't approve of, but that has nothing to do with social security. Government deficits can impact social security indirectly, of course, as I pointed out in my post above.
 
Quote from peilthetraveler:

Average person makes about 50k per year. SS taxes are 6.2% meaning the average person puts $3100 per year or about $250 per month into it. Assumming no inflation that would mean the average person working over 40 years puts $124k into it. The average person claims SS at 65 and the average american dies at 78 which means 13 years to collect benefits. So if there was no inflation and no interest earned on that money collected, SS breaks even paying out $794 per month. Obviously with inflation, and interest earned on the money in the SS account, they can pay more when you finally retire.

Social security, as you can see isnt really a ponzi, its just a forced community savings account where you lose everything you put in if you die before 62 (or 65 or whatever age you choose to collect)

I agree. However do not forget about disability coverage, survivor benefits to spouses and dependent children. Also consider that if you live well beyond age 78 you can not outlive your benefits. And yes, you will receive a monthly check well in excess of $794 for as long as you live and it will be indexed to inflation, whereas had you funded your retirement privately with bonds paying the same interest as those in the Trust Fund, all the while paying disability insurance premiums out of your contributions, and then on retirement paid yourself the same monthly amount you would receive from social security, it won't be too many years before you run out of money.
 
Quote from MattF:

So, I'm 31. Just got that nice little letter in the mail from SS that says where you are "at" in the benefits dept. <gag>

If I stopped working at age 62 and took the benefits, I'd get a nice $740/month.

67? $1,066/month
70? $1,322/month

Of course I paid 8800 in over 14 years of "working." (crap jobs) Talk about a quick return...if it's even around then :D (although it's still poverty levels as is)

Of course, the letter STILL states that "even if modifications to the program are not made, there would still be enough funds in 2037 from taxes paid by workers to pay about $760 for every $1000 in benefits scheduled."

So comforting...

For the smarter ones working the system, this may go too from today:

"An obscure strategy that allows Social Security recipients to boost their income by repaying benefits received in earlier years and then claiming a bigger monthly check based on their older age may soon disappear. Kiplinger's has learned that the Social Security Administration is moving to eliminate the so-called do-over strategy. If the agency gets its way, the new rule could take effect within a few months."

Man my generation is gonna be so screwed....they have NO idea....

You can see from your own numbers what a good deal social security is for you in particular. You definitely won't get "screwed" as long as congress gets busy and makes the necessary adjustments soon. If you possibly can, you'll want to contribute to a Roth IRA or some other supplemental retirement plan, because you can't live very well on social security alone. It is mainly intended to prevent impoverishment in old age. There won't be enough to pay for the gardener, maid, and pool boy.
 
Quote from peilthetraveler:

Pssshh...you obviously have never been out of the United States if you think that. At least 80%(probably more) of the world would trade places with a middle class american. If you think middle Americans get screwed, go check out the factories in India or china. Then you will see what screwed really is working 16 hour days for 62 cents per hour. THATS screwed.

Everyone in the United States lives like a king compared to most of the rest of the world. Even our homeless can make 100 bucks per day begging.

What's your point? Average poor people in the rest of the world would love to trade place with the "poor" people in the US too. Where in the world that you don't have to work and get a roof over your head and get food, medical and money for free?
 
Quote from peilthetraveler:

Average person makes about 50k per year. SS taxes are 6.2% meaning the average person puts $3100 per year or about $250 per month into it.

The employer puts in an additional 6.2%. If you are self-employed, you pay the whole 12.4%
 
Quote from thecalip:

".. Where in the world that you don't have to work and get a roof over your head and get food, medical and money for free?

America, Finland, Denmark, Sweden??
 
Quote from JoePaterno:

The employer puts in an additional 6.2%. If you are self-employed, you pay the whole 12.4%
unless you are self employed as a trader as most on et should be. then you pay nothing.
even if you are self employed as a trader it is important that you find a way to pay in enough to qualify for ss.
 
Back
Top