So is the venerable Peter L. Brandt a fake trader?

What do you think?

  • Yes

  • No

Results are only viewable after voting.
That link doesn't really say anything.

I read PLB's book years ago - he was on Realvision more recently, maybe a couple of years back. I'm agnostic as to his veracity, other than to say a sustained 40% ROR from a sole operator lacking a structural edge (ie not scalping broker flow in the pit) is nothing to sneeze at - and a CPA attestation is more than 99% of gurus and FinTwit personalities will ever produce.
 
Sounds like these two have been battling it out for years.

tenor.gif
 
I dont know about this Peter Brand guy, but I was in a chat room earlier this year for 3 months and the guy running it would make consistent LIVE calls on ES / CL, not 100% accuracy obviously but very good. He even posted the occasional DOM screen shots. Still there are lots of people that think that guy is a fake trader. Some people just dont want to believe that its possible.
 
Specterx said:
That link doesn't really say anything.

I read PLB's book years ago - he was on Realvision more recently, maybe a couple of years back. I'm agnostic as to his veracity, other than to say a sustained 40% ROR from a sole operator lacking a structural edge (ie not scalping broker flow in the pit) is nothing to sneeze at - and a CPA attestation is more than 99% of gurus and FinTwit personalities will ever produce.
More...

Well, now. It does say something.

1. how about the NFA disciplinary action? I mean that's a fact.

2. the link actually questions the verification of this 40% annual returns.

3. also, he does delete tweets where he predicted wrong price action. fact.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top