Simplicity

Status
Not open for further replies.
I agree posting here is a waste of my time, It had been a long time since I trolled some message boards. So long Elite Traders.
 
If you're still checking this thread out jrs3:

The only way that the 3 min chart looks like yours is for it to be set on 24 hour data, otherwise the macd patterns and the post 16:00 data do not match. Regardless, with mine set on 24 hour it matches yours.

I'm guessing from the time diff on the bottom of your chart that you are an hour behind eastern.

Are you saying the 10 period ma is an EMA? It appears that the buy and sell signals generated are primarily based on the change in direction of the histogram. How does the ma play a part in the trading process?

Thanks, it is interesting, and I can see the need to take every trade, otherwise you could easily just get chopped around and never catch the nice ones. When do you enter, on the close of the signal bar, or the open of the next bar, etc. ?
 
Quote from dbphoenix:



Rather than a confirming oscillator in the same bar interval, find one oscillator that you like for that interval (which you may already have done with the histogram), then use the same or a similar oscillator in the next-higher bar interval, such as the 5m if you're entering off the 1m/2m. This will most likely provide a better trade filter.
More...

Yes DB...that is a good idea. I already look at several time frames with the indicators.

The point of overlaying these is the "change" signal often comes on one indicator before the other. Gives an early heads up.

But it comes down to how an individual sees things. 2 oscillators for some is an unnecessary complication. Others like it to provide confirmation.
 
Quote from BuddhaTop:

What about forgetting about all these indicators and oscillators and just follow the trend, buy support, sell resistance. I cannot do that yet, but this should be the way to go.
More...


Damn, I wish it was that simple.:cool:
 
jrs, listen, you come here and you shout something out. a concept, whatever. are you willing to engage in a constructive discussion to demonstrate the concept's merit? or you are choosing to be a "sensitive one" and run? if you're ***REALLY*** open to sharing and helping I suggest you start a thread in the Journals section. Where you demonstrate this system in action, taking ALL trades like you said. Don't need to do it for a year. A week would give most people a good idea.
 
Quote from traderkay:

jrs, listen, you come here and you shout something out. a concept, whatever. are you willing to engage in a constructive discussion to demonstrate the concept's merit? or you are choosing to be a "sensitive one" and run? if you're ***REALLY*** open to sharing and helping I suggest you start a thread in the Journals section. Where you demonstrate this system in action, taking ALL trades like you said. Don't need to do it for a year. A week would give most people a good idea.
More...

Why can't you still get it, that nobody even thinks of sharing anything after he had a taste of the response that provokes that on this site. Yours not in the least.
 
...I have found that if you post something serious as if it were a joke, a hoax, or a complete crock, you get more interesting responses and PMs than if you play it straight.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top