Ironplates, maybe you are misunderstanding me. Yes this contract stops trading at 3pm central time. Yes this contract has no pin risk, as it is cash exercised.
But the value of each contract is based on the settlement price of the SPX on that day. The settlement price is not known at 3pm ct, the SPX will continue to move after the options close, thus affecting the value of the options. So if you sell the 2020 puts at 2:59:59ct, for 1 and the index shows 2019.50 1 second later at 3:00ct you have not locked in .50. The index will continue to tick after 3:00, Even though the options are closed. You have no way to hedge this risk. The index may fall another 1 over the next minute, AFTER the close and you would then have a loss.
But the value of each contract is based on the settlement price of the SPX on that day. The settlement price is not known at 3pm ct, the SPX will continue to move after the options close, thus affecting the value of the options. So if you sell the 2020 puts at 2:59:59ct, for 1 and the index shows 2019.50 1 second later at 3:00ct you have not locked in .50. The index will continue to tick after 3:00, Even though the options are closed. You have no way to hedge this risk. The index may fall another 1 over the next minute, AFTER the close and you would then have a loss.