Quote from Thunderdog:
My earlier comment was in connection with marketsurfer's ongoing defense of everything Niederhoffer (of the Victor variety).
I'm not prepared to comment on Buffett's performance because his time frame is outside of my experience and context. However, there is no denying the man's genius in the fullness of time. I am also not denying Dennis his due, although he is obviously not in the same league as Buffett and had his own notable stumbles.
However, I am prepared to comment on marketsurfer's sycophantic adulation of VN. And so I do. On a risk adjusted basis, VN's trading performance does not compare well with many of the people marketsurfer incessantly criticizes. No one disagrees that, all else being equal, a higher return necessitates a higher level of risk. However, what marketsurfer fails to accept or recognize is that all else is not equal. Demonstrably, VN's risk was more outsized than the return that such risk generated.