Quote from jem:
Were those answers really worth writing?
I hope so...
1. When everyone is on your side of the trade... you are wrong.
Unless you're right, of course...
2. having traded for a living I am always leery of the obvious result.
You're not the only one. You don't have to agree with my views. My conclusion regarding the expected path of the drachma/EUR exchange rate seems obvious, because, as I have mentioned already: a) it's based on fundamental macroeconomic principles; b) similar events have occurred before.
3. I had no desire to turn this into a Fed bashing debate.... but...
I refer you to Greenspans record of controlling a bubble by lowering rates and allowing liar loans. i thought central banks were supposed modulate cycles not exacerbate them. I will defer to guys like Thomas Jefferson?
Thomas Jefferson wrote:
"The [privately-owned] Central Bank is an institution of the most deadly hostility existing against the principles and form of our Constitution...if the American people allow private banks to control the issuance of their currency, first by inflation and then by deflation, the banks and corporationsthat will grow up around them will deprive the people of all their property until their children will wake up homeless on the continent their fathers conquered."
If you want to talk about Greece and not about the Fed, why do you keep mentioning the Fed, its various (ex)Chairmen and Thomas Jefferson? My point to you is that the Greek situation is all about basic macroeconomics. Central Banks and central bankers, even if they're 6ft+ tall and are called Paul Volcker, are not magical entities that can twist the fabric of macroeconomic reality at will.
4. If Volker was involved with a new Greek Central Bank would you really still make an bet on inflation.... I brought him up as an example of how perhaps a central bank should be run. Now do you see the connection .
No, I don't see any connection. In fact, you've convinced me that you're marvelously confused. What does inflation have to do with anything? When did "bets on inflation" ever come into this? As to Volcker, see above.
5. In the world of Sovereigns we have Bono getting debt forgiven a loans from the IMF. Debt forgiveness is a lot like bankruptcy --- don't you think?
I don't know anything about IMF loans to Bono, but I just don't understand what this has to do with Greece and sovereign debt. What is your point here?
6. Its odd you say that because the moral of Volkers story is that a little short term pain while he crushed inflation expectations... set the U.S. up for a 15 year expansion. Bernanke just spent how many trillion to avoid pain.
He changed agency debt in to treasury. he spent how many trillions on bad assets.
Again, what does this have to do with anything? We're talking about Greece and you're comparing Volcker to Bernanke? Apart from the obvious issues with the way you're making the comparison, what does this have to do with Greece?
The story about Soros has turned into marketing cliche my 10 year son knows it.
Why don't you tell us who was the money behind Soros. That would be a useful reply.
Was it the Martians? Britney Spears? In all honesty, I always thought it was Soros... But yet again, even if it were the Martians, what does this have to do with anything? I brought up Soros and the ERM to illustrate an obvious point; namely that raising rates doesn't necessarily imply a strengthening of the ccy, while causing pain to the domestic economy.