Requirements for a Mentor

Quote from Boib:

From Shea, Gordon F. (1997) Mentoring (Rev. Ed.). Menlo Park, CA: Crisp Publications.


Sounds like your patient wants to be a Vendor.

No, he has no interest in becoming a vendor. The definition of mentor or teacher if you will is appropriate in this case. That is not to say, however, that he is a saint who will spend his time doing this for free--he wants to charge a fair price for the value received, which I think he is entitled to.
 
Quote from 123Magic:

Thanks, but not real helpful. I don't see much difference between the two. He has a successful track record. Size is about risk and ones bankroll.

The above statement lets me know that you're for real. If you've got the other parts covered (the usual entry/exits that everyone seems to concentrate 90% of their attention) AND he/she is as good as you are, I'd say 3k-5k for 2 weeks to 1 month of hardcore tutelage, + an added for an additional 6 months of hand-holding (if required) for additional fees ... then it's time for them to fly.

Jimmy Jam
 
Quote from Pekelo:

Reading comprehension 101: He wants to be a mentor, he just doesn't know how to go about it...

One can only wonder about his patients ...

JJ
 
Quote from Wayne Gibbous:

Who needs a mentor?

Do it on your own.

The market is my mentor.

Ole "Lone Wolf Wayne"


Good trading to all. :cool:

Wayne, you might be correct. One of the big questions here is whether or not there is a need for this type of service to make it worth persuing and yet not make this a marketing juggernaut like Traders International, RSofHouston and others of that ilk. Ditto for Web vendors like Puretick, Falcon Day Trading, and Kingfish.
 
Quote from 123Magic:

Knowing that ET has a tough crowd, I though I'd ask what you would require or want to see from a professional trader who would offer services as a teacher/mentor to train others how to trade on a one to one basis. Also, what do you think would be a fair fee for those services? Frankly, I'm not sure there is much of a demand for this type of service.

This is a serious inquiry, not for me, but one of my patients who wants to wind down from the world of day trading. He only trades the ES.

Thanks in advance for your serious comments.

I've never had a coach or mentor but there was a decent article on this in the April issue of SFO Magazine.

"Trading Coaches Needed"
http://www.sfomag.com/issuedetail.asp?MonthNameID=April&YearID=2007

Damon
 
Taking your word that the guy is a successful trader, how will one know if he will be a successful teacher?

I would suggest he take on one or two students for little or no cost, or possibly a percentage of their trading profits, and see if he can actually teach.

If he is a successful teacher, he should be able to charge whatever he wants. The problem will be convincing people he is a successful teacher.

If he is known as a successful trader in the local community he should have no problem finding students to experiment with.
 
In a similar vein, start with a few people, charge a "smaller" fee and then increase it from there depending on what the workload turns out to be. You could operate face-to-face, over the telephone or via instant messaging.
 
Quote from Boib:

Taking your word that the guy is a successful trader, how will one know if he will be a successful teacher?

I would suggest he take on one or two students for little or no cost, or possibly a percentage of their trading profits, and see if he can actually teach.

If he is a successful teacher, he should be able to charge whatever he wants. The problem will be convincing people he is a successful teacher.

If he is known as a successful trader in the local community he should have no problem finding students to experiment with.

Of course he's prepared to show his trading statements and allow those who are serious to confirm those results with his broker. He has no interest in a profit sharing arrangement with his students in lieu of a tuition fee. That's akin to going to law school for free and then having the university get a slice of the students future legal fees.
 
Quote from 123Magic:

Of course he's prepared to show his trading statements and allow those who are serious to confirm those results with his broker. He has no interest in a profit sharing arrangement with his students in lieu of a tuition fee. That's akin to going to law school for free and then having the university get a slice of the students future legal fees.

So you saying that because he is a successful trader he will be a successful teacher?
 
Quote from 123Magic:

That's akin to going to law school for free and then having the university get a slice of the students future legal fees.

But Law schools have a proven track record for teaching. Lots of documentation that this or that school turns out successful lawyers.
 
Back
Top