From Bloomberg email newsletter few days ago:
And finally, here’s what Joe's interested in this morning
Yesterday I wrote about the
rapid rise in permanent unemployment. While the vast majority of people who have lost their jobs so far in this crisis are technically on temporary layoffs -- people who hopefully will go back to their old roles when the virus is beaten -- a number of jobs are already gone for good.
Here's another way of looking at it. For a long time,
Bill McBride, the great blogger at the site
Calculated Risk, has been putting together a
great chart comparing the trajectory of job losses in different recessions, and you can see how this crisis looks nothing like other recessions. Just totally different in scale and shape.
But of course, most of the job losses in prior recessions weren't initially characterized as temporary, so the comparison isn't exactly apples to apples. So I asked him to make a version that looked just at permanent layoffs. And the chart at this point looks like this.
The glass half-full scenario here is that permanent job losses are still not nearly as deep as last time. So far in this crisis, we've lost just over 1% of jobs on a gone-for-good basis. On the other hand, these losses starting off way faster and way steeper. And in the meantime, the massive stimulus has already gone out the door, and we still haven't gotten the virus under control.
Either way, in a sense, it's this red line, not the exaggerated line from above, that gives the clearest picture of the recession, since it represents clear economic damage, as opposed to virus mitigation efforts. As Washington D.C. gears up for another round of stimulus talks, this is the chart to think about, with a goal of preventing it from getting as bad as last time. It's arguably not as bad as last time yet, but the direction so far is way worse.