No, it would still be random because it would be something that just came to someone's mind to post. Every post here is random, because these postings are all just something that popped into someone's mind. There is no topic.
I can only speak for myself, but I'm personally glad that our posts in ET are run horozontally, rather than vertically or diagonally. It makes it easier for me.
I fully support your claim. I would venture to say there's a high probability of you being correct. A straight line dividing the bulls from the bears is usually best.
I never had a trading mentor, and hereby instate you with retroactive effect.
I would like to hear what song pops into any of your minds. If this happens to you, post it here.
This can happen to you at any time, at any place. You could be preparing for the market, eating lunch, driving, talking to your girlfriend, doing school work, talking to your boss, at any time or place.
Let me know if I've planted this into your subconscienceness or if this is something that happens to you, normally.