Questions to Jack Hershey

baro-san · Mar 7, 2012

Quote from Nebuchadnezzar:

... with that in mind examine todds charts for consistency

and ask yourself

the person claims to be able to do such and such tasks, and yet the charts posted indicate quite the opposite

in fact locate all his charts and see if any b2b's or r2r's were followed by the anticipated market action on the next day

It seems that you use anticipated with a different meaning that I'd use it in relation to Hershey's method. Maybe here's gist of our different experiences with this method. As you say that you see the same thing on all his charts, it should be easy for you to post a two day example where the sequence failed.

MarketMasher · Mar 8, 2012

I called the low in the morning today using the PinkyBlue.

Did anyone see the sell-off that happened 2 days ago coming?

Pinky did.

I don't have time to post charts, but I say so, so believe it.

RedDuke · Mar 8, 2012

Not sure if it was done yet, but I can fully automate it.

Ninja 7 allows access to multiple instruments within the same strategy/indicator.

Someone need to list the exact rules. I have ES 5 min data going back to March 2007. So we can back test it, and once and for all give the answer if it works or not.

Just too much hype about this topic over the years.

ocean5 · Mar 8, 2012

Quote from RedDuke:

Not sure if it was done yet, but I can fully automate it.

Ninja 7 allows access to multiple instruments within the same strategy/indicator.

Someone need to list the exact rules. I have ES 5 min data going back to March 2007. So we can back test it, and once and for all give the answer if it works or not.

Just too much hype about this topic over the years.

Alway wondered,wht`s the point to monitor MULTIPLE instruments with the same strategy/indicator!!!What`s the frakin POINT!!!

MarketMasher · Mar 8, 2012

Quote from RedDuke:

Not sure if it was done yet, but I can fully automate it.

Ninja 7 allows access to multiple instruments within the same strategy/indicator.

Someone need to list the exact rules. I have ES 5 min data going back to March 2007. So we can back test it, and once and for all give the answer if it works or not.

Just too much hype about this topic over the years.

I do my own coding for the PinkyBlue - so I guess you are talking about the JH method.

Wow - what an opportunity to have it laid out in discrete, unambiguous language!!

I would help, but I don't know WTF they're talking about...

baro-san · Mar 8, 2012

Quote from RedDuke:

Not sure if it was done yet, but I can fully automate it.

Ninja 7 allows access to multiple instruments within the same strategy/indicator.

Someone need to list the exact rules. I have ES 5 min data going back to March 2007. So we can back test it, and once and for all give the answer if it works or not.

Just too much hype about this topic over the years.

This sounds like a phishing email I just received:

Dear Sir/ma

Due to the congestion in all our users and removal of all unused Accounts, We would be shutting down all unused Account. You will have to confirm your Account by filling out your Information below after clicking the reply button

Username:
Password:
Country(at sign up):

After following the instructions in the sheet, your Account will continue as normal. Thanks for your attention to this request. We apologize for any inconveniences.
Thank you
Warning Code:VY2E96AAh

MarketMasher · Mar 8, 2012

The exact rules should be easy enough for someone who really knows the system to lay out.

Ever read "Street Smarts" by Raschke and Connors? It's several bullet points per setup (usually they give the Buy-side rules and just say "reverse for shorts").

For instance, because I know the PinkyBlue code, I could articulate very concisely what the rules are.

So it will be really interesting to see how the experts in the JH system pitch in and show the world some Awesomeness!!

Nebuchadnezzar · Mar 8, 2012

Quote from MarketMasher:

So it will be really interesting to see how the experts in the JH system pitch in and show the world some Awesomeness!!

They will not. They prefer to support learning simply by claiming 3X ATR daily like paddler and such

Nebuchadnezzar · Mar 9, 2012

Quote from RedDuke:

Not sure if it was done yet, but I can fully automate it.

Ninja 7 allows access to multiple instruments within the same strategy/indicator.

Someone need to list the exact rules. I have ES 5 min data going back to March 2007. So we can back test it, and once and for all give the answer if it works or not.

Just too much hype about this topic over the years.

The rules are very simple: enter on ftt, monitor for change or continuation on your trading fractal, reverse if what must come next doesn't, add contracts as needed, wash , rinse, repeat, teach others to make 3 times daily range. Those rules are the ones that you need to hear as opposed to those that you want to hear.

Stop phishing.

Do the work.

MarketMasher · Mar 9, 2012

Quote from Nebuchadnezzar:

The rules are very simple: enter on ftt, monitor for change or continuation on your trading fractal, reverse if what must come next doesn't, add contracts as needed, wash , rinse, repeat, teach others to make 3 times daily range. Those rules are the ones that you need to hear as opposed to those that you want to hear.

Stop phishing.

Do the work.

Pinky has done work. On the PinkyBlue.

Thanks to his Herculean efforts, he can now see inside the bars.

This was not easy, as it required a brilliantly inspired modification to what at first blush is a nondescript item.

http://www.google.com/products/cata...=X&ei=yQ5aT4efFI_RrQeLgbWHDA&ved=0CIEBEPMCMAE

I think in the JH, the trader is supposed to monitor the bracketing fractals in the JH method also, but I should let the experts articulate the real rules cogently and concisely.