Questions to Jack Hershey

Quote from Xspurt:

You should be very grateful for Jack. He gives your life meaning and purpose. Without Jack you'd have nothing to offer, nothing to post.

However your obsession is unhealthy and is screwing up your mind. Try and imagine what life would be like if you could trade - it would give you another focus and perhaps wean you off Jack.

Start up a How-I-Trade thread and help others. Jack might even help!
More...

He is the starter of A Simple Profitable Method. But Jack was dominating these boards back then, before they moved to TL. T28 never recovered from that.
 
Someone who I have on ignore has replied to this thread.

My parameters for this thread are: if you have something negative to say, without having first dug into the methods, you are on ignore. I do not even bother to read your posts past the first sentence.

JH has worked tirelessly for a long time to give people a way to view the markets. Anyone who does not give this a fair hearing gets the ignore button.

Have a nice day.:)
 
Quote from RCG Trader:

Someone who I have on ignore has replied to this thread.

My parameters for this thread are: if you have something negative to say, without having first dug into the methods, you are on ignore. I do not even bother to read your posts past the first sentence.

JH has worked tirelessly for a long time to give people a way to view the markets. Anyone who does not give this a fair hearing gets the ignore button.

Have a nice day.:)
More...

So we give him credit for the good old college try of "working tirelessly?" While Jack has made some few good observations, the vast majority of his oeuvre is errant nonsense. Uncountable noobs here have been led ass-tray by his gookledegobb, and we have every two years or so a well-documented case of one who tried and crashed and burned. But worse, persons of low or no character have been discouraged from trying trading by Jack's pious insistence that a successful trader must be a modern day Knight Templar.
 
Quote from nkhoi:

good to see you back I am not so thrilled with other guy, too sane!
More...

As always, you are too kind. Since Jack is so good at misleading people unintentionally, all that is left for me is to do so with intent. If fools believe in SCT, then why not tempt them to believe it can be done in 50 EFS SLOCs or less?
 
If one has been led astray by Jack or anyone posting on an internet forum, the that's ones own damn fault.

Really, grow up.

Quote from Joe Doaks:

So we give him credit for the good old college try of "working tirelessly?" While Jack has made some few good observations, the vast majority of his oeuvre is errant nonsense. Uncountable noobs here have been led ass-tray by his gookledegobb, and we have every two years or so a well-documented case of one who tried and crashed and burned. But worse, persons of low or no character have been discouraged from trying trading by Jack's pious insistence that a successful trader must be a modern day Knight Templar.
More...
 
Quote from Joe Doaks:

As always, you are too kind. Since Jack is so good at misleading people unintentionally, all that is left for me is to do so with intent. If fools believe in SCT, then why not tempt them to believe it can be done in 50 EFS SLOCs or less?
More...

I believe you have captured the essence in less than 20 lines... probably 19 more than necessary..
I consider myself an expert in hindsight analysis, annotating after the fact, remarkable ability to tell you the outcome of yesterdays charts. With this strong background I would like to offer my assistance if ever you need it.
 
A stimulating exercise, not unlike a red pepper enema. The chart shown is NQ. Alas, it doesn't work nearly as well for ES. But a successful emulation of all the nasty whipsaws in SCT.
 

Attachments

You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top