You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
question for Trade-Ideas users
- Thread starter in56
- Start date
Quote from reg:
Your buddy DiamondTrim has posted the most number of positive statements about Trade-Ideas than anyone here on ET.
I would consider that spam.
He's not a moderator on this board, and from what I saw his posts were on topic. If you read that opinion how does that help anyone. At least the guy who made a negative comment before described what he thought was the problem.
Quote from IGolf:
He's not a moderator on this board, and from what I saw his posts were on topic. If you read that opinion how does that help anyone. At least the guy who made a negative comment before described what he thought was the problem.
Do you have any solid proof that the said moderator's purpose in writing that particular review was to spam? What if it was his honest opinion about Trade-Ideas based on his experience?
Are moderators not entitled to their opinions?
You have been so deluded into thinking that Trade-Ideas is the best product out there that you probably never even bothered to try out the other stock screening products that are available in the marketplace. A year ago, you were inquiring on this board about Whisper and got no responses. Were you resourceful enough to actually get your hands on that piece of software? And no, I am not talking about Trader's Paradise. Trader's Paradise is Bill Kingsbury's version of Whisper, not the full version itself.
Open your eyes a little bit more and you might actually find a way to improve your trading.
Quote from IGolf:
I just noticed that the last and negative opinion about Trade-Ideas was posted by a moderator and it looks like spam. Very strange for a message board like this
WTF...does Sternforpres sound like a moderator name? That's Howard Stern for President to decode it for you.
I am a satisfied and happy user of TI since 2004. My post was not intended to be negative, nor was it.
Quote from reg:
Do you have any solid proof that the said moderator's purpose in writing that particular review was to spam? What if it was his honest opinion about Trade-Ideas based on his experience?
Are moderators not entitled to their opinions?
You have been so deluded into thinking that Trade-Ideas is the best product out there that you probably never even bothered to try out the other stock screening products that are available in the marketplace. A year ago, you were inquiring on this board about Whisper and got no responses. Were you resourceful enough to actually get your hands on that piece of software? And no, I am not talking about Trader's Paradise. Trader's Paradise is Bill Kingsbury's version of Whisper, not the full version itself.
Open your eyes a little bit more and you might actually find a way to improve your trading.
Ok so that was easy. You use whisper and you were the other guy who gave the bad review, and no offense but based on your comments it is clear you HAVE ZERO idea as to how Trade-Ideas works so that is all good and I have no problem with you thinking that it sucks, to each his own. My friend DT was banned from this board so you don't have to worry about him spamming although oddly enough I did a search and one if his last posts recommended TradeStation RadarScreen and did not mention TI....hmmm..
I personally looked at two versions of whisper one with Ontime Alerts and the other one you mentioned before. For me you simply can't even compare the power. Trade-Ideas is easier and way more powerful. My suggestion to you learn how to use a product, that way you might be finally able to take your trading to the next level instead of being stuck in 1992 which is what I felt it was like looking at a whisper screen.
Quote from IGolf:
Ok so that was easy. You use whisper and you were the other guy who gave the bad review, and no offense but based on your comments it is clear you HAVE ZERO idea as to how Trade-Ideas works so that is all good and I have no problem with you thinking that it sucks, to each his own. My friend DT was banned from this board so you don't have to worry about him spamming although oddly enough I did a search and one if his last posts recommended TradeStation RadarScreen and did not mention TI....hmmm..
I personally looked at two versions of whisper one with Ontime Alerts and the other one you mentioned before. For me you simply can't even compare the power. Trade-Ideas is easier and way more powerful. My suggestion to you learn how to use a product, that way you might be finally able to take your trading to the next level instead of being stuck in 1992 which is what I felt it was like looking at a whisper screen.
DT was banned from this board - wonder why?
I guess your reading comprehension is not so good, so let me say it one more time: Traders Paradise (and resellers of Whisper like Ontime Alert) are NOT the FULL VERSION of Whisper.
I trade at a prop firm and the version of Whisper that we use includes customized alerts that make Trade-Ideas look like a toy.
The cost of Whisper to us is 4x more than TI, but we're willing to pay up since the advantages in more profitable trades more than outweigh the cost disadvantage.
I had initially wanted to point you in the right direction when you first made your inquiry about Whisper last year (again, I am NOT referring to Traders Paradise or Ontime Alert or any of Whisper's resellers), but you sounded like a guy who didn't know his ass from his elbow at that time (and even now) so I didn't want to bother.
By the way, I have been a member of ET since 2001, and this is the first time that I am mentioning Whisper (in fact, I didn't even mention it in my review on TI). This means I am NOT spamming for Whisper and am in no way affiliated with them aside from being a satisfied user. In fact, the less people who use it the better for us.
Quote from IGolf:
I did a search and one if his last posts recommended TradeStation RadarScreen and did not mention TI....hmmm..
Did you do a search as to how many times he mentioned Trade-Ideas vis-a-vis TradeStation RadarScreen?
You yourself seemed surprised that your buddy didn't mention TI on his last post. LMAO!
Quote from reg:
Did you do a search as to how many times he mentioned Trade-Ideas vis-a-vis TradeStation RadarScreen?
You yourself seemed surprised that your buddy didn't mention TI on his last post. LMAO!
I know DT well and he helped me get a lot out of TI. From what I saw he talked about TI on posts where it was appropriate. I am certain based on my experience and what you said about the cost you will have no trouble with very few people using Whisper. Your magic is safe. Why did you start posting on this thread anyways since it was for TI users?
Quote from IGolf:
I Why did you start posting on this thread anyways since it was for TI users?
This thread was "Question for Trade-Ideas Users" and not "Good Reviews of Trade-Ideas from Trade-Ideas Users" or "Question for Current Trade-Ideas Users." Do you see the difference?
I posted on this thread because I wanted to and because I was a TI user at one time.
Quote from IGolf:
I know DT well and he helped me get a lot out of TI. From what I saw he talked about TI on posts where it was appropriate. I am certain based on my experience and what you said about the cost you will have no trouble with very few people using Whisper. Your magic is safe. Why did you start posting on this thread anyways since it was for TI users?
Reg I have a suggestion for the both of us. Why don't we try to be more constructive and mature. Let's do a real comparison between the two products and see what makes them tick and why we each think one is better than the other. Maybe instead of just talking shit we could help the other people on this board. It seems like the scanner threads get a lot of views so I believe people would be interested. Are you in?