My opinion at this poit is to focus as you are on trading daily. I will work to get the 10 SCT textual streams rolling along with the four appendices.
It is not going to be possible, as you say (unfounded) to deal with TA in the TA forum.
By emphasising trading in a trading forum we can back into the TA basis of SCT.
In ET there is a coming recognition that it is not possible for everyone to trade commodities. In fact, mostly everyone should start with equities for several reasons.
SCT is different that the CW (Conventional Wisdom). The basic pervasive connection SCT has to the P, V relation is SCT's foundation and as has been stated, CW is the opposite of the P, V relation precept.
This opposite viewpoint has to add a whole series of non TA fixes to compensate.
The basic test of efficacy of TA concepts is if they work throughout the spectrum of the separate time durations of the operation of markets. I use seven durations to perform the efficacy tests.
Thee are no aspects of SCT that have not passed this efficacy test.
Here in this thread in the Trading forum, we have the capability to set standards of quality. I will make a strong effort to do just that.
The bottom line is how trading performance reflects quality of the methodology. ET has consistently rejected the prints and logs and charts. That is no longer my concern at this point. The information is on record, searchable and part of the archives that are asscessable. So is the commentary on the facts that were presented. The commentary is based upon where the commentor's operate. That is they view what trading is from a viewpoint that is unable to show there is a comprehension of either the P, V relation nor its manifestation in equities trading nor the SCT or the beginnier or intermediate ramp up to SCT.
This is an SCT thread. It is not a place for beginners nor intermediates to participate. It is not possible for anyone to respect this as we all know by now. Using advanced beginners as moderators precludes moderation at all. We know this and understand this.
I am just a support to the trading record being built here in real time where an association of traders are using their methods to trade and they are continuing to iteratively refine those methods.
Were it possible for people to ask questions primarily, instead of do what they do, the iterative refinement would be better implemented. At this point I conclude that it is not possible for beginners and intermediates to understand the results of the current trading in real time. That will not change.
I am going to pick up the pace on delivering the basics of SCT trading. I interviewed a new person this week and we purchased a new computer for getting an archiving process formalized here. The terrific illustrations so far are still accessable from the TA thread I will use them as well.
The four elements of using TA in real time, monitoring, analysis, decsion making, and timely action, is the essence of making money. So trading in real time, supported by methodology segments and iterative refinement should serve everyone quite well.
I'll make a counterpart for the attached QA/ROI (Quality Assurance/Return on Investment) chart soon.
