Question for Grob/Hershey
- Thread starter Stalker
- Start date
- Status
easyrider,
just like Jack/Grob you skirt the issues, use condescending language and engage in ad hominem. If you set out to be his student, you are to be commended. You are well on your way.
If you notice, I said 'simple minded newbies'. I didn't say all newbies.
In any case, as I and others have said over and over again, all he has to do is give trades (entry, stop loss, and exit).
If you notice, I gave respect to spydertrader because he is doing exactly that. This is nothing personal. Not against you, and not against Jack.
Yet he refuses to do this simple thing. And rambles on and instead with Fidel Castro like endurance.
Anytime you want to actually own up to the issues I raise - rather than engaging in condescension (referring to me as 'Babs'), ad hominem, misdirection and evasion - I'm here to be proven wrong.
In the meantime, in the 'Dummies' journal I'll continue to show a simple pattern that can be explained to a 16 year old in 30 minutes and implemented profitably.
BTW I called to have him removed because he ceaselessly insults and degrades people (as you can see by the posts a few pages back). This is unacceptable and just because you've accepted him as your lord and saviour doesn't mean the rules here don't apply to him.
Simple, channel on YM. Pt1, Pt2, Pt3. If I'm being super sharp, I'm on the first bar extensions and gathering all continuation aspects (ie. primarily price extensions of the current bar wrt to the previous bar) and a confirming PRV (ie. greater PRV volume on the current bar wrt to the previous bar). I stay super focused at least thru 10 am since synch and reversals are at times on the table and require swift immediate action.
Here is an exceptional picture...
http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/attachment.php?s=&postid=829612
Note the 4 current bars on the ES (the opening bars of 08.31.05). Then look at the corresponding 12 bars of the YM (ie. on the right). The ES shows R2L traverse ensuing. The YM has cycled R2L, then L2R, and is continuing R2L again within the same 4 bars of the ES traverse... I am heavily tuned into this action...
MAK!
Can you show me where I've insulted Jack/Grob like that? When speaking about him, I do speak negatively but never personal insults like that. I refer to his methods and means of communication - which are undecipherable. Or that he refuses to put up and show us real trades or statements. Referring to someone's lack of clarity and inability to string together a logical sentence is not an insult. What Jack/Grob said (above)...now that is clearly an insult.
But I guess since you're one of the chosen, anything he does is ok with you. You even laughed and joked about it. Wonder if you would have laughed and joked about it if I called Jack/Grob an asshole or used the F-word?
Now who's the hypocrite?
Others???
"entry, stop loss, exit" - our trading modus has nothing to do with any of these terms. It is only "HOLD" and "REVERSE". You are repeatedly stating how it is that we are different. Have you considered why it is that we would be different or are you insistent that what you do and what we do is the same.
Does the following set of actions look equivalent?
(entry, stop loss, exit) = (hold, reverse)
(entry, stop loss, exit) <> (hold, reverse)
MAK!
Yes, others. Check the archives and you'll see.
Call it whatever you like, ham, apple and broomsticks. All he does is jibba jabba. He never shows real trades. All he has to do is get in the ET chat and go through his trades for one day.
Will he take this challenge?
One day in the ET chat, giving real time entries and exits.
How about it?
I've got a plate of crow ready and waiting. I'm putting my bib on. All he has to do is accept the challenge.
(mmmm...that crow sure smells good!)
How about it?
Call it whatever you like, ham, apple and broomsticks. All he does is jibba jabba. He never shows real trades. All he has to do is get in the ET chat and go through his trades for one day.
Will he take this challenge?
One day in the ET chat, giving real time entries and exits.
How about it?
I've got a plate of crow ready and waiting. I'm putting my bib on. All he has to do is accept the challenge.
(mmmm...that crow sure smells good!)
How about it?
:eek:
Where's the TA??
Where's the TA??
- Status