Prove to me that Technical Analysis Works.

[wmwmw]

OK, You posted a couple of charts so let us see your time stamped trade getting long around 10:10 and selling around 3:20. Serious question here: Are you all talk or did you actually make this trade. It is easy to identify this trade after the fact. A 10 minute chart and any basic moving average clearly shows what a nice trade that would have been.

10:10 am was not a good entry. 11:00 was.
I entered at 11:00 am and held to close.
Both 10:10 and 9.30 spikes were traps.
If I entered 10:10, I would need to cut loss 20 munitues later per my signal.

 

[MacBookProHo]

It is easy to identify this trade after the fact.

A 10 minute chart and any basic moving average clearly shows what a nice trade that would have been.

'Moving Averages'....yea, sure,....if trading were as easy as following and tracing lines...there would be so many rich people all around. Instead, there are angry, depressed, moody zombies, cattle and sheep all around.

What I'm saying is I know the underlying logic, rationale, and process behind the scenes and curtains that make the expected market movement move the way it generally does before it does. And the Holy Grail is knowing of the future.
I'm not necessarily giving anything away, but I have yet to see any trader anywhere fully explain why the market moves the way it does every day. In the same process fashion that I understand it, and expect it to move.

 

[Illini Trader]

I think we are talking time zone differences here as 10:00 or 10:10 bars are good entries Central Time but not Eastern time.

 

[Illini Trader]

'Moving Averages'....yea, sure,....if trading were as easy as following and tracing lines...there would be so many rich people all around. Instead, there are angry, depressed, moody zombies, cattle and sheep all around.

What I'm saying is I know the underlying logic, rationale, and process behind the scenes and curtains that make the expected market movement move the way it generally does before it does. And the Holy Grail is knowing of the future.
I'm not necessarily giving anything away, but I have yet to see any trader anywhere fully explain why the market moves the way it does every day. In the same process fashion that I understand it, and expect it to move.

You and wmwmw have a lot in common as you both make the same claims of understanding.......... You made another post MacBook, but still no proof that you made the trade. Proving the trade is not giving any of your secret sauce away as you have already told us you made the trade. (or at least strongly implied that you did)

 

[schizo]

What I'm saying is I know the underlying logic, rationale, and process behind the scenes and curtains that make the expected market movement move the way it generally does before it does. And the Holy Grail is knowing of the future.
I'm not necessarily giving anything away, but I have yet to see any trader anywhere fully explain why the market moves the way it does every day. In the same process fashion that I understand it, and expect it to move.

There's no disputing that you talk like a GURU. In fact almost all your posts are the same. Big on words without anything to back up the tall claim.

But, funnily, this is also what you wrote earlier in another thread. Do I sense a double standard?

It's wrong, unethical, immoral....and should be illegal....to teach/sell something with which someone has NO PROOF of proficiency and competence, and expertise, wisdom and experience. They are simply selling the Dream of your own ATM money machine to all the dumb, small, people out there.

 

[MacBookProHo]

There's no disputing that you talk like a GURU.
In fact almost all your posts are the same. Big on words without anything to back up the tall claim.

But, funnily, this is also what you wrote earlier in another thread. Do I sense a double standard?

I'm not all over social media being a John Carter, Tim Sykes, Warrior Trading, Ken Calhoun, Jason Bond, Steven Dux, and Many Others.
I'm just here on ET, being anonymous, not selling anything... sharing my golden words of wisdom for free. Not asking for money, Sales.

I have no conflict of interests or reason to lie, or some agenda to promote for my personal gain.

 

[Illini Trader]

Fair Enough, I will look forward to more golden words of wisdom for free.

 

[deaddog]

Fair Enough, I will look forward to more golden words of wisdom for free.

You get what you pay for!!

 

[wmwmw]

You and wmwmw have a lot in common as you both make the same claims of understanding.......... You made another post MacBook, but still no proof that you made the trade. Proving the trade is not giving any of your secret sauce away as you have already told us you made the trade. (or at least strongly implied that you did)

Why you need proof.
What benefit a proof can bring? Nothing.
If I provide a proof someone pays me money, then I will make the proof.

 

[Illini Trader]

Was not talking to you