Prop trader vs. trader @ major IBs

so how does someone good get found?..

I'm young, good education, very profitable .. at the moment trading own money and advising but looking to expand network. ..perhaps join a firm or fund.

or better to join a prop firm? trading on my own is boring and there's always lot's to learn from other great traders.
 
If you check on a Bloomberg, there's a section on Jobs, there's tons of postings everyday from hedge funds and prop funds looking for profitable traders.
 
Before opening your mouth and answering a question such as the one the thread starter started, you should really do a little research on the subject matter.

Based on your answer here, its very obvious to any experienced trader that you are very clueless on what prop trading is all about. I'm not trying to be a dick, but you are new here and need to understand that its not helpful or productive for someone like you to comment on something you know very little if anything about. I suggest, for future posts, that you spend a little more time getting to know the topic before responding.


Quote from Batman28:

hello,


prop traders USE the banks money to trade. They have a buy-low sell-high strategy.

sale-traders - as theyr known (not sales people) execute customer trades, and aim to make profit on the spreads.

prop tradres are typicaly the big dogs. theyr kinda oldish.. theyr the dadys. they make the most money - and lose most too. they get paid the most too.. some bond traders make millions a year.

they dont use sophisticated technology. actually if u havent met one, ud laugh how 'normal' they are.. nothing out of this world about them.. they use the same ideas as everyone else but with more expereince and gut feelings.. i met some big dawg couple of weeks ago, he didnt even look at technicals. he was weird though, he told us how the market speaks to him like a person, and he made himself and hes traders make notes on what the market was telling them every day lol he was nuts.


but generally, props buy low, sell high. no shorting.
 
Quote from Steve Tvardek:

Before opening your mouth and answering a question such as the one the thread starter started, you should really do a little research on the subject matter.

Based on your answer here, its very obvious to any experienced trader that you are very clueless on what prop trading is all about. I'm not trying to be a dick, but you are new here and need to understand that its not helpful or productive for someone like you to comment on something you know very little if anything about. I suggest, for future posts, that you spend a little more time getting to know the topic before responding.

There are a couple of definitions of prop trading floating around.
 
Quote from Batman28:

hello,


prop traders USE the banks money to trade. They have a buy-low sell-high strategy.

sale-traders - as theyr known (not sales people) execute customer trades, and aim to make profit on the spreads.

prop tradres are typicaly the big dogs. theyr kinda oldish.. theyr the dadys. they make the most money - and lose most too. they get paid the most too.. some bond traders make millions a year.

they dont use sophisticated technology. actually if u havent met one, ud laugh how 'normal' they are.. nothing out of this world about them.. they use the same ideas as everyone else but with more expereince and gut feelings.. i met some big dawg couple of weeks ago, he didnt even look at technicals. he was weird though, he told us how the market speaks to him like a person, and he made himself and hes traders make notes on what the market was telling them every day lol he was nuts.


but generally, props buy low, sell high. no shorting.


having said that, recently banks have started seting up hedge-fund like teams..like GS and MS.

see below a recent news:


"April 13, 2006 -- Morgan Stanley has created an all-star team of bond traders to wager its own cash in the market, a move that is raising eyebrows of its crucial hedge-fund clients.

Bond executives at Morgan told The Post the change will put clients' needs first, rather than focus on longer-term trades for the investment bank's own account, which is "kind of opposed to the idea of customer business," according to one trader.

All told, about 30 of Morgan's asset-backed bond traders, analysts and technology specialists are moving to a different floor at the firm's headquarters.

A senior Morgan executive told The Post that feedback from mutual and pension funds "has been excellent. They are always concerned about us being distracted or putting ourselves first."

However, he acknowledged that hedge funds "might have some concerns."

The chief investment officer at a $5 billion Midtown hedge fund called the arrangement "a hedge fund with a lower cost of capital, pure and simple."

Morgan, he said, "will compete with us for product, and their best traders are off the desk."

The move comes as Wall Street's biggest firms have evolved into something close to hedge funds. They are using massive capital bases and access to cheap capital to place huge bets for their own accounts.

Proprietary trading might be the last great gold rush on Wall Street. Morgan's primary competitor, Goldman Sachs, earned $16.3 billion in net revenue trading for its own account last year.

The hedge-fund executive said fighting the trend toward greater prop trading was useless.

"What's the difference between having a separate [prop] group versus a Goldman that takes the same kinds of risks on the various trading desks?" the executive asked. "



You made yourself look very unknowledgeable with this post. If I were you I would immediately change my screen name.....this one is officially BLOWN UP:eek: :D
 
Quote from Steve Tvardek:

Before opening your mouth and answering a question such as the one the thread starter started, you should really do a little research on the subject matter.

Based on your answer here, its very obvious to any experienced trader that you are very clueless on what prop trading is all about. I'm not trying to be a dick, but you are new here and need to understand that its not helpful or productive for someone like you to comment on something you know very little if anything about. I suggest, for future posts, that you spend a little more time getting to know the topic before responding.


Quote from Batman28:


holy mother of god.. first u calm ur ass down. secondly, i wasn't talkin about 'prop trading' like 'prop shops'.. you're not being a dick at all.. you're being a asshole. i think i know much more about prop traders at banks than u do.

by the way, im not being a dick.

and yes i am new here. so what. i suggest u do some research on who u think ur talking to before opening ur mouth like a clueless kid. i think i've met more prop traders at IBs than u have in ur life and I think i know more about the difference at banks and prop shops than u. if u want to discuss it, write something constructive, rather than flaming.

now if you have something to say, start by answering the question of the thread starter, otherwise don't nag like you're some big dady.

have a nice day.
 
Quote from mizer:

You made yourself look very unknowledgeable with this post. If I were you I would immediately change my screen name.....this one is officially BLOWN UP:eek: :D

hey kido, can u tell me exactly why i should change my screen name?

im really surprised at the number of "unknowledgeable" folks here actually, given that its a traders forum.. i guess thats because not everyone is from london or NY and make assumptions of how the world turns.

anyways, im not going to waste my time. have a nice day.
 
I did some research on you Mr. "Batman" You mentioned in one of your posts that you arent even a trader! And then you have the nerve to answer questions about prop trading. Get a life bro. I trade at a prop firm and have for 3 years so I think I know more about the subject than you.

The thread starter was asking about the difference between trading at an IB vrs "prop trading". Maybe its YOU who should go back and re-read the thread starters post because you obviously are confused. I dont give a shit if you werent talking about prop trading at a prop shop, but I believe the thread starter was.

My posts to you have nothing to do with the fact that you are new to elitetrader, we were all new here at one point. My issue is that you have no idea what you are talking about as far as this subject is concerned. Wise up man.




Quote from Batman28:

holy mother of god.. first u calm ur ass down. secondly, i wasn't talkin about 'prop trading' like 'prop shops'.. you're not being a dick at all.. you're being a asshole. i think i know much more about prop traders at banks than u do.

by the way, im not being a dick.

and yes i am new here. so what. i suggest u do some research on who u think ur talking to before opening ur mouth like a clueless kid. i think i've met more prop traders at IBs than u have in ur life and I think i know more about the difference at banks and prop shops than u. if u want to discuss it, write something constructive, rather than flaming.

now if you have something to say, start by answering the question of the thread starter, otherwise don't nag like you're some big dady.

have a nice day.
 
Here is the post in case you forgot.


Quote from Batman28:

and i assume you enjoy giving people money freely too (and legally) huh? :D ;)

what i want to know is how did u got into. did u wake up someday and thought you're made for this? or it was ur childhood dream..

im not a trader but ive always wanted to be one as far as i remember.. i think it all started with when I watched Wall St. :D
 
Back
Top