Prop Shops That Pay You To Trade?

"This is another key point. Being able to do this consistently for 10 or 20 years. I know a lot of guys that can do anything well for 2 to 5 years, its longevity that matters in this business. Where do you think GOOG's stock price would be if they said tomorrow they only seem themselves making money for another 3 to 5 years then thats it. I think it would be a $5 stock. Any guy can jump into a trend or a hot market and milk it for a year or two, I'm talking about traders that can trade for 10 to 40 years. Yes, they are out there."


If you are truly good at trading futures, there is no need to trade them for longer than 3-5 years. Hit your licks and put the money in other investments and once the pressure is off to make big money, live life.
 
Quote from Maverick74:

I'm going to say something that might offend a lot of people on here. But to be honest with you, I really don't care. The fact of the matter is, I can count on one hand how many profitable futures traders I have heard of. Not guys that I know, but guys that I have heard of from other prop firms. While it may be true that only 10% of traders in general are able to eek out a living, I think that number drops to about 2% when we talk about pure outright futures traders.

Now having said that, why should a firm put up their risk capital to get behind a guy where there is a one out of fifty chance he will ever makes a dime? I certainly would not make that bet nor would anyone on this board. This is the problem we are faced with.

If you want a salary job as a trader, let me put you in a few directions. One is risk arbitrage with a major bank or hedge fund. Another is automated trading/writing algorithms, etc. for a major bank or hedge fund, the other is a sales trader on an OTC desk for a major bank.

I'm sorry to report this, but there simply is very little out there in the way of salary for discretionary, fly by the seat of your pants/cowboy, futures traders, and for good reason. You have no EDGE!

My best advice I can give is put a good resume together, start faxing it out to every firm you can think of, brush up on your statistics and probability skills, and hit the pavement.

I was fortunate enough to attend a lecture just last week at the downtown campus of IIT here in Chicago. They happen to have an outstanding trading curriculum there. The keynote speaker is one of the professors there who happens to be one of the brightest guys I have ever met, a former quant from Bell Labs.

He has traded OTC products for Morgan Stanley in NY, ran one of the largest bond options desk in London and currently has started his own firm. He gave a rundown of the current job market here in Chicago for traders. He said there was a plethora of opportunity out there for bright young guys that can write code and algorithms, and guys that can do advanced derivative pricing for large banks and hedge funds.

He has placed several of his students with many of these banks and firms. But outside that area, there is very very little available. Unfortunately, if you don't have these credentials, you are going to have to pay to play. You are going to have to take risks and make sacrifices. You are going to have to PROVE yourself with YOUR money. IF, and this is a huge IF, you somehow find a way to make a little bit of money, then, and only then, will a few doors SLOWLY start to open up for you in terms of getting backing of some sort.

Again, I know this is not what people want to hear on this thread, but it is very real. I cannot believe for the life of me how many guys on this web site come to me or others asking for money with their hands out with not a single shred of a track record or any evidence that there is a remote chance that they will ever make a dime.

I don't know who to blame for this, late night infomercials, Trader Monthly Magazine, or possibly all the misinformation on this site by guys who claim they make millions yet don't even have a real account opened. Either way, there are more professional athletes today then there are profitable independent traders.

Many of you would have better luck hitting the gym and trying out for the Chicago Bears practice squad. Flame me all you want, but if you don't believe me, I can give you names and phone numbers of all the shops here in town and you can see for yourself.



Then why do you even attempt to try to teach those at your firm to trade ES ?
 
Quote from volente_00:

Then why do you even attempt to try to teach those at your firm to trade ES ?

I have amended this statement somewhat in previous threads. Although I stand by most of it. Most futures traders I have met are unprofitable. But I have put together a decent training program here based loosely off my days trading stocks in NY and the work of trading legend Mark Fisher. And the guys in my office, including myself are doing well with it. That is why I'm teaching them to trade index futures.

But this doesn't change the fact that where ever I go, most guys I meet that say they trade futures, are not ultimately not profitable. I think one of the reasons behind this that a lot of futures traders are guys that fell under the PDT rule for stock trading and migrated over to futures. I don't think one should be trading futures if they are undercapitalized and most of them seem to be.
 
Quote from Hydroblunt:


I do think it's funny how Maverick rags on futures prop firms, when the equity side ones have not been able to afford real prop deals for years. Only true equity prop firms are Schonfeld and FNYS. And only FNYS can afford to pay salary and is extremely selective, plus they are above the in & out daytrading.
Meanwhile the futures firms will only do real prop deals and pay a salary/draw. So there must be something about futures, and I do believe there are still some barriers.

Hydro, everyone in our office trades futures. I don't recall ragging on futures firms. Just on the fact that the success rate for futures traders in general seems to be smaller then stock or option traders.
 
Quote from Maverick74:

I have amended this statement somewhat in previous threads. Although I stand by most of it. Most futures traders I have met are unprofitable. But I have put together a decent training program here based loosely off my days trading stocks in NY and the work of trading legend Mark Fisher. And the guys in my office, including myself are doing well with it. That is why I'm teaching them to trade index futures.

But this doesn't change the fact that where ever I go, most guys I meet that say they trade futures, are not ultimately not profitable. I think one of the reasons behind this that a lot of futures traders are guys that fell under the PDT rule for stock trading and migrated over to futures. I don't think one should be trading futures if they are undercapitalized and most of them seem to be.



Ok, I just remember you talking with Don about index futues and was confused. I agree the game is hard and takes time to learn. Most never make it though the losing curve. That is the beauty of futures that lures in the money to be taken. The simple fact that you can trade a 70k instrument with only $500 margin is what keeps the game alive.
 
Quote from volente_00:

Ok, I just remember you talking with Don about index futues and was confused. I agree the game is hard and takes time to learn. Most never make it though the losing curve. That is the beauty of futures that lures in the money to be taken. The simple fact that you can trade a 70k instrument with only $500 margin is what keeps the game alive.

I don't remember being confused. I think that was Don. I spent a good 30 minutes talking about nothing but futures at the end of the chat.
 
Quote from Maverick74:

I don't remember being confused. I think that was Don. I spent a good 30 minutes talking about nothing but futures at the end of the chat.

What? I've never been confused about anything - maybe delusional, but never confused.

Don :D

(Besides, we being the same person is confusing enough).
 
Quote from Maverick74:

Hydro, everyone in our office trades futures. I don't recall ragging on futures firms. Just on the fact that the success rate for futures traders in general seems to be smaller then stock or option traders.

There is a very good reason for this. Its MUCH easier to enter the futures trading world with very little capital and no training. Many have no clue what they are doing as it does take a long time to get proficient. Add the leverage they play with, and its no wonder that most don't last. Its a wonder that any do.They get blown out before they learn the game.

I also have done both, and I find index futures much easier (execution and volatility being most important to me)

As for the "direction fantasy" mentioned by Don, this may be true with equities in the current environment, but not with many futures markets. They have large ranges and trend very nicely most days. There are many futures day traders that trade direction only (I am one, although I aim for very small pieces of a trend). When I worked in one of Don's offices in the late 90's, many of the guys there were making cash taking direction as well. This was due to the volatility, not just the prevailing up direction. Big money was made on the down days as well, although we spent a fortune on bullets.

Jay
 
Back
Top