It doesn't really matter where a trader starts. As long as he starts somewhere, ideally using other peoples money. Most traders on their own struggle just to find one profitable strategy and still get that wrong. Being in an environment where there are profitable traders, however they make their money is important. Teaches so many things, especially how to carry ones self, and what traits the profitable traders exhibit.
But not only that, give a newbie time to figure out the basics of trading and wether they even like it or not.
Personally I think it's rediculous for new traders to put their own money on the table, why not play at a prop for a year or two, cut your teeth, then go it on your own if your confident.
And when you trade other peoples money, it takes the emotional roller coaster experience out of the game.
And while your doing that, read every book and watch every dvd you can, then lose 50 to 100 grand of your own money, and only then if you've paid your dues, you will start to become profitable consistently. And then the money flows easily after that.
Good luck.