stevesbg,
I agree. I also stated the method was working for me and it was ignored, but as soon as someone says they've struggled with it the trolls take that as evidence the method stinks. You can't win.
I joined this thread to converse with other Logic traders, not to have to prove to outsiders that it works. Isn't there a place where like-minded traders can freely discuss the nuances of their methodology?
As for the ones struggling with it, I don't know how much effort they have put into it, but if they have tried and are unable to make money with it it doesn't mean there is no hope. Sometimes being shown a few things can turn things around for somebody. Unfortunately the discussion always gets thrown off track.
Let's say Prof didn't even participate in this thread, are we to believe that we would be left alone? So this didn't turn to garbage because a few individuals were calling out the vendor - some people are just very negative. I don't know Mandelbrot, but I expect his 5000 posts on ET are of a similar tone to what we've seen here.