Quote from Nexen:
Can you please elaborate on what you consider price action ?
You lost me, I thought PA was a form of TA but without indicators.
There are basically three types of Price Action traders I've seen identify themselves.
#1 - Those that trade price action without charts via using for example time & sales with bid/ask screens only.
#2 - Those that trade price action with charts but without technical indicators (e.g. macd, rsi, stoc, moving averages, volume)
#3 - Those that trade price action with charts with a few indicators that they don't consider to be technical indicators (e.g. moving averages, volume).
All the above is technical analysis and that's where the debate occurs because I've seen traders from all the above say it's not technical analysis. I've seen even some of Elitetrader.com most well known outspoken TA haters have discussed a few of their traders via a chart example or analyze the markets via charts or use line charts of some economic data to validate the reasons behind their trades.
I've concluded traders can call themselves whatever they want and agree with whom ever they want. Outside of that...it's wasted time & energy in debating about the issue. Similar to some profitable stock traders that do trade futures sometimes (profitably) get on a stage and say there aren't any profitable futures traders. Yeah...I guess everybody is right as to say that there is no right or wrong.
Mark