Preemptive Nationalization To Save US - The Shortie Solution

Nationalize US or Not?

  • Nationalize Now

    Votes: 5 10.9%
  • Leave Everything The Way It is

    Votes: 30 65.2%
  • I prefer not to state my opionion due to fear of political prosecution

    Votes: 11 23.9%

  • Total voters
    46
Quote from shortie:

The current political/economic system has outlived itself. For decades the rich were getting richer while the poor were getting poorer. There is not much incentive for the guy at the bottom to work hard, be creative, etc. because it won't get him anywhere. At the same time there is no incentive for the rich dude to do anything productive for thee society because the money is flowing his way pretty much regardless of what he does.
I agree with everything you said except the "nationalize" part. I think heavy taxation is the only way to 'wake' up the rich. Make them invest in job-creating ventures (or pay 1950's tax rate)


historicaltaxrates.gif
 
Quote from Bob111:

yeah..in your dreams..fuck you..you share your money with bums...I'll move..just like before...just like many russians move in 1917 out of russia look at that country and learn from real example what may happen if all rich people leave...btw-many of them settle here and they done a lot of things for this CAPITALISTIC world..read history once again..show me advanced communistic country..what is the point to work,if you have to share with bums anyway? you didn't explain that..

do you plan on living >100 years?

you do raise an important issue of the rich leaving the country once they learn that my plan has a chance. i am not sure what to do about that. any suggestions?
 
I don't know why no one ever bothers to point this out, but for most folks poverty is age-related.
As in, you're poor when young, get more prosperous until you're in your 50s, and then gradually start shedding that wealth until you die.
You can actually see this in the Census figures. I'm too tired to look it up now but if I can I'll find the table that shows this tomorrow. It also accords with real life, of course. Even Bill Gates seems to be going through this cycle. Only Buffett can't seem to get enough.
Also, poor folks, mostly, are the opposite of classically lazy: they work on jobs with weird shifts, frequently have more than one job, and of course tend more towards manual labor than richer folks. Everyone focuses on the beggars and the welfare folks, but the working poor work hard, regardless of whether they take advantage of food stamps or Medicaid.
Your average middle class finance guy, OTOH, gets all the holidays, works regular daytime hours, the hardest manual labor he has to do is click the keys on his office computer, he lives in a house with a mortgage subsidized by the government in more ways than I can be bothered to list right now, and of course has a good health care plan in large part because his company gets a tax writeoff on their contribution to his premium.
He's probably a member of the Tea Party anyway.
 
Quote from shortie:

do you plan on living >100 years?

you do raise an important issue of the rich leaving the country once they learn that my plan has a chance. i am not sure what to do about that. any suggestions?
yes. why not.. sooner than later FOR PROFIT corporations(with no bums in it) will be able to produce and change your organs just like car parts..

here the movie for you,enjoy-

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tIeics8jHUY&feature=related
 
Quote from walter4:

I agree with everything you said except the "nationalize" part. I think heavy taxation is the only way to 'wake' up the rich. Make them invest in job-creating ventures (or pay 1950's tax rate)


historicaltaxrates.gif

?????????

why do the rich need to be woken up?

i cant fathom how people think the solution is to take the rich to the wood shed, makes no sense at all. complete and utter bullshit.

shortie proposed his "solution"

here is mine

fire every senator and house rep. re-elect with new laws they have to abide by. no more unlimited perks and all the other corrupt bull shit that is going on.

deport osama and pelosi

elect a new president that is inline with what needs to change. One that has a set of balls, and can do what needs to be done.

close all military bases around the world, bring all the troops home.

all the money that is saved from the military goes into technological defense that we use from here-------------- thats right, we do not go anywhere sticking our nose in other peoples problems. if someone fucks with us, like the taliban, then we send the fucking house after them everyone goes and we squash them in a week. none of this horse-shit of slapping them on the wrists.

we no longer are the worlds crutch, we start looking after ourselves and get shit done here instead of all over the world. fuck the rest of the world.

if the shit hits the fan and its a nuke fest then its a nuke fest and everyone is gone.


enforce our borders

round up and deport all illegal aliens ------- every single one of them



end the irs-------- flat tax or consumption tax--- bada bing bada bang, economy turns around over night.

cut the government down to its knees---------- start over------- small gov't ------ like it was supposed to be in the beginning


if you are poor and do not like the the new America--- then get the fuck out.

if you have money and do not like the new America then get the fuck out.


or we could just do shorties plan :confused:
 
Quote from walter4:

I agree with everything you said except the "nationalize" part. I think heavy taxation is the only way to 'wake' up the rich. Make them invest in job-creating ventures (or pay 1950's tax rate)

...

wealth redistribution via taxation is done by the government and the govmt is amazingly inefficient at whatever it does. if higher taxes were the answer we would not be in the trouble we are in.

that's the reason i like a major once-every-hundred-year tax however unfair it may seem. after the giant one time tax it is every man for himself to take the best advantage of capitalism.
 
Quote from QuikrRetirement:

I would like a response to what I said above:

the bottom 50% pay almost no taxes. The top 50% pay almost all the taxes (growing rapidly as income rises). So the govt services, roads, justice systems, debt payments, defense, medicaid, education for the poor, food stamps for the poor, section 8 housing for the poor, welfare for the poor, energy subsidies and a lot of other services all come from the richer.

In addition, most of the jobs that the poor have are likely also from the rich - who start, grow, take risks or fund most of the companies as well as the buildings in which they exist. That also includes the military/govt jobs that the rich also provide by supporting the govt

The top also disproportionately purchases more of the luxury and retail purchases that employs an awful lot of the poor.

If the rich left the country suddenly, the poor would be in a living hell.

If everything was redistributed, the poor would be poor again within 10-20 years.

Your generalization is entirely backwards and entirely wrong.

Quote from shortie:

you are reciting the situation now. i am trying to look forward.

i think the end of the world as we know it may be near because the system is broken. if the current system were healthy i would vote with both hands to keep it intact. today we could try doing something or just wait and see what happens when the global economic shit hits the fan.

as far as the current poor becoming the new poor in 10 years - that's fine. some will even become poor in 1 year, for others it may take 30-40 years. after they have a clean start it is their problem. but many folks will actually have much better chances to succeede than what they have now. they will be new gates and buffetts. and in 100 years we will reset the scale again.


Ignoring the fact you addressed none of the realities that I said and pretty much none of the very pertinent points of others...

A forum is a place that people are allowed to exercise their right to express their thoughts.

It would be useful if you started a lot fewer threads though, until you received an education, and stopped trying to become a bastion for ignorant thinking. I have seen other of your threads, and you should be blocked from starting polls and threads.

There is a saying that to a child with a hammer, everything looks like a nail. You are currently that person. So I am exercising my right to put you on ignore. No hard feelings.
 
Quote from QuikrRetirement:

Quote from shortie:

you are reciting the situation now. i am trying to look forward.

i think the end of the world as we know it may be near because the system is broken. if the current system were healthy i would vote with both hands to keep it intact. today we could try doing something or just wait and see what happens when the global economic shit hits the fan.

as far as the current poor becoming the new poor in 10 years - that's fine. some will even become poor in 1 year, for others it may take 30-40 years. after they have a clean start it is their problem. but many folks will actually have much better chances to succeede than what they have now. they will be new gates and buffetts. and in 100 years we will reset the scale again.


Ignoring the fact you addressed none of the realities that I said and pretty much none of the very pertinent points of others...

A forum is a place that people are allowed to exercise their right to express their thoughts.

It would be useful if you started a lot fewer threads though, until you received an education, and stopped trying to become a bastion for ignorant thinking. I have seen other of your threads, and you should be blocked from starting polls and threads.

There is a saying that to a child with a hammer, everything looks like a nail. You are currently that person. So I am exercising my right to put you on ignore. No hard feelings.

after my solution is implemented everybody will pay a flat tax. i hope you are happy.
 
Quote from Petsamo:

With Obama & the Democrats confiscating wealth and screwing things up, "nationalize now" and "leave everything as it is" are essentially synonyms.

Shortie, you useful idiot !

this is the obama agenda.

during the crisis of 2009 there was talk of the government taking over 401k plans.
 
Back
Top