I read a comparison/contrast of Gann and Elliot. Whereas the Gann trader uses time and price to identify support and resistance, for example, at 5000, observes price movement at such a juncture and trades accordingly, The Elliot Wave trader goes short at 4998.65 and goes broke at 5250. They are always adjusting their wave count after the fact. Prechter said the SP would not pass 890 this past fall.
TA of Stocks and Commodities had an interview of some guy who told of going short some high flying internet stock in 1999-2000. He was 75 points in the red but convinced of his wave count so he held the short (which eventually turned his way,like all internet stocks). Some accuracy!
Like any guru in the markets clamoring for attention, if you make a drastic pronouncement and you turn out correct, you get rich, as followers will buy your worthless newsletter, but if you are wrong, big deal. Guru-ing is a low risk endeavor,unless you are trading your own ideas, in which case you have an historical probability of 99.98% of going broke.