Potential NQ Targets

If I was a newbie wanting to learn daytrading, I'd sure want to learn from someone who had better timing than sitting through 30+ ticks of heat. New/small account traders have zero reason to do this. How much heat do you need to know you're wrong?/quote]

Not to interrupt the broadcast, but I wouldn't be so quick to assume everything is daytrading related.
 
You posted this at 5 mins after the open. I have the high for this minute at 4026 (Dec). Lets (generously) assume you were filled here. 10 mins later, market is at 34.25. You're 33 ticks offside.

The failure at 4040 was yesterday afternoon.
 
The failure at 4040 was yesterday afternoon.
Maybe it was, but we're sure not going to give you the benefit of the doubt of shorting at an earlier / better price than the time of your post, unless of course you post a blotter/statement showing your fill.

That's just basic honesty. Fact is market went offside after you posted your short call. It is now unchanged from when you posted. You've not called an exit. So onus on you to post where you entered and exited if you want to keep any credibility. There is no consistent reason why you'd post trade calls and then refuse to state where you got in and out.
 
Indeed.
Sure it is. Link me to the post where you've advocated, before today, that your "apprentices" with their "price action" journals carry their positions overnight. Why would you advocate newbies to take the risk of holding futures contracts, which they are probably using leverage to hold, through the close?

These guys just keep on moving the goalposts when challenged. First the trade was put on earlier and at a better price than available when the call was posted. Now its not a daytrade. Real useful.
 
The failure at 4040 was yesterday afternoon.

And yet despite this being the "NQ targets" thread you didn't give a target for your call. So no way to know where you would have sought to get out. And now the market is trading above where you sold.
 
Maybe it was, but we're sure not going to give you the benefit of the doubt of shorting at an earlier / better price than the time of your post, unless of course you post a blotter/statement showing your fill.

That's just basic honesty. Fact is market went offside after you posted your short call. It is now unchanged from when you posted. You've not called an exit. So onus on you to post where you entered and exited if you want to keep any credibility. There is no consistent reason why you'd post trade calls and then refuse to state where you got in and out.

There's no onus on me to do anything other than be consistent. Other than that, I'm under no obligation to satisfy some anonymous stranger on a trading forum. If you want to know why I posted what I posted, read my journals. Or be a PITA. Which you choose depends on whether or not you want to learn something.
 
There's no onus on me to do anything other than be consistent.
Just short a failure to hold above 4040.
You posted the short call at 0935 EST today. "just short" means the immediate past, not yesterday afternoon.
The failure at 4040 was yesterday afternoon.
Then the market went up for 15 mins after you posted "just short".
So did you actually trade. Can you show us a blotter (live or sim)?

Can you show us a clearing firm statement from yesterday showing where you initiated a short NQ trade and carried it overnight?


I'm just here to make a point. That you won't be transparent, won't be consistent, won't show your fills, and basically won't substantiate why anyone should pay the slightest bit of attention to what you write let alone follow your trading suggestions. You're not a profitable trader.

In an industry with so many frauds it is incumbent on those wishing to be taken seriously to show some bona fides. The only people who listen to you are those too lazy or greedy to do any due diligence. You've been wasting aspiring traders time for over a decade online and I really wish you'd just cut it out.


DB won't post any evidence to back up any of his claims to have traded long or short.
 
And yet despite this being the "NQ targets" thread you didn't give a target for your call. So no way to know where you would have sought to get out. And now the market is trading above where you sold.

Surely you must understand that "targets" in this context are (road)maps. If you drive your car and suddenly discover that the bridge is not there (any longer), what do you do? Drive right into the river? Or adapt to the situation? We're not playing a rigid structure, but how other people view current situations.
 
Back
Top