Quote from Dogballoon:
An organized and unequivocal reaction from ordinary citizens? Gotcha. Like, say, the organized reaction from ordinary U.S. citizens when soldiers massacred civilians in Haditha, shooting children and old men in the head? Or Abu Ghraib? How about an organized unequivocal reaction from ordinary Catholics for the sexual abuse of children?
Well... I can't really match up the image of a rogue soldier murdering a bunch of people with the 767 hitting Tower 2, you know. Something about that that I just can't match up...
In the case of Abu Ghraib, considering the play the story got here, it's not like we had nothing to say about it.
With regard to the Catholic priest problem, that's a better analogy, but have you heard about a Catholic group coming out in defense of the latest pedophile with the argument that he is 'disenfranchised' and the victim of 'clerical profiling'? Secondly, the Catholic priests have not sent video tapes in to CNN saying 'children of the flock beware, we are going to anally rape every one of you'.
Quote from Dogballoon:
But the moment a Muslim from North Africa burns a car in Paris, boneheads expect entire Muslim communities in Canada to beg for forgiveness.
Actually, no. It was the moment that they flew those planes into those buildings, killing what, 2300 + people? It was that moment.
And no, I don't expect them to beg forgiveness. I just expect them to refrain from saying that the problem is that Muslim youth are 'disenfranchised', and to distance themselves from their brothers and sisters who say that the Holocaust never happened and that their goal is to wipe every Jew off the face of the planet and then establish a worldwide Islamic state in which unbelievers are beheadable according to Islamic law, and where Sharia is the order of the day.
To be honest, I think the problem is fear of reprisals. Most families here have relatives in the ME, and there is no doubt in my mind that if a Westernized family started speaking up in an organized manner, there would be hell to pay for the relatives back home. As RM has pointed out, honour is everything in Muslim culture, and when someone does something 'wrong', the entire family is shamed.
By the way, I just read a transcript of a recent interview with Ahmedinejad. I can guarantee you that there aren't any pedophile Catholic priests or rogue soldiers or military jail commanders who are also leaders of nations.