Isn't there a rule that requires that when showing real time results those claims must be verifiable ?
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Poll: Is it humanly possible to capture 3x ATR everday?
- Thread starter jsmith
- Start date
Isn't there a rule that requires that when showing real time results those claims must be verifiable ?
Quote from vikana:
If Jack actually wanted to settle this dispute he could do it in a few seconds by simply posting a few months worth of account statements.
In stead he chooses to spend hours posting long rambling incoherent messages, often unrelated to trading.
Just questioning this is ridiculous.
It can't be done, end of argument, it's impossible to do what the poll says.
Anek
Going back to the topic of this thread, some key information is missing in the question:
- 3X ATR on what timeframe? I assume you implied daily ATR.
- What ATR period? 21? 14?
If we take daily ATR set at 14, current reading for ES would be around 21 pts.
3 times that equals 63 pts.
Now another question arises: what kind of position sizing do you have in mind?
What's your capital size?
If you trade 63 contracts it will only take 1.25 ES pts to achieve that- comissions included -
If you trade 2 contracts at the time, I guess it's a very long shot to achieve that.
The question is badly formulated and it's missing key information, so no answer can be given IMO.
- 3X ATR on what timeframe? I assume you implied daily ATR.
- What ATR period? 21? 14?
If we take daily ATR set at 14, current reading for ES would be around 21 pts.
3 times that equals 63 pts.
Now another question arises: what kind of position sizing do you have in mind?
What's your capital size?
If you trade 63 contracts it will only take 1.25 ES pts to achieve that- comissions included -
If you trade 2 contracts at the time, I guess it's a very long shot to achieve that.
The question is badly formulated and it's missing key information, so no answer can be given IMO.
Quote from fseitun:
Going back to the topic of this thread, some key information is missing in the question:
- 3X ATR on what timeframe? I assume you implied daily ATR.
- What ATR period? 21? 14?
If we take daily ATR set at 14, current reading for ES would be around 21 pts.
3 times that equals 63 pts.
Now another question arises: what kind of position sizing do you have in mind?
What's your capital size?
If you trade 63 contracts it will only take 1.25 ES pts to achieve that- comissions included -
If you trade 2 contracts at the time, I guess it's a very long shot to achieve that.
The question is badly formulated and it's missing key information, so no answer can be given IMO.
When traders talk about points, they refer to points per contract.
Uninitiated amateurs might think differently.
Quote from vikana:
If Jack actually wanted to settle this dispute he could do it in a few seconds by simply posting a few months worth of account statements.
In stead he chooses to spend hours posting long rambling incoherent messages, often unrelated to trading.
I'm curious Vikana, what do you think of your fellow moderator callmate deleting any negative posts about Jack and leaving his supporters posts? in effect a one sided argument in any thread she moderates.
Do the moderators speak to each other and try to adhere to a certain level of integrity? Or is it just a free for all where a Hershey devotee like callmate or nkhoi can just do as they please and flout their own rules?
Just looked at the poll result, and it says 21% think it is possible. I don't know whether it is the same jerk voting yes multiple times, but in case it represents the actual ratio from viewers of this thread, I am appalled at the amount of gullibility out there - or should I say crass ignorance.