POLL for traders who trade the Jack Hershey method(s) in real time with real money

[Bearbelly]

Quote from Tradetime:

And do you actually believe volume leads price yet BB?

Its not a belief any longer. I know that volume leads price . It is the best reversal indicator out there, imho.

 

[Bearbelly]

Quote from Tradetime:

Nope, had my IP banned 3 times here, takes seconds to get around it (I have cable)

Only three??????

 

[Bearbelly]

March has been my best month ever and brought my account back into the black after being down the first two months so yes I am profitable but my whole account probably doesnt amount to one good trade for some of you guys. Nevertheless it is progress.

 

[trader225]

Quote from PointOne:

Sure, happy to help:

For any market, on any time frame, price Continues to progress, up and down, within a sloped channel until market sentiment Changes and price begins to follow a new channel of opposite slope. When the SCT trader sees signs of Change on the time-frame he is monitoring he reverses, otherwise he holds (having decided to enter in the first place on seeing Change). The rate of change of volume helps the trader differentiate between Continuation and Change, provided sufficient liquidity exists.

They should make you the SCT 'splainer.
Jack and his crew don't have your abilities.

 

[Trader666]

Absolutely not! Cutting through the pseudointellectual babble to lift the veil of mystique would surely hurt the effort to recruit newbies.

Quote from trader225:

They should make you the SCT 'splainer.

 

[thenewguy]

Quote from Trader666:

Absolutely not! Cutting through the pseudointellectual babble to lift the veil of mystique would surely hurt the effort to recruit newbies.

Just out of curiosity, why do you think Jack wants to recruit newbies?

TNG

 

[HolyGrail]

Quote from Tradetime:

I would step around you like you were standing still princess

Maybe so, but most couldn't and that is all that really matters if you want to keep a clean board.

 

[bighog]

Anyone that follows someone else ideas about trading in toto are fools. Face it, you follow a quack because individually you have proven yourself a failure in the trading game.

How many gurus have popped out of the woodwork in the last few decades and promise even less than quackjack and turn to dust soon after?

Look in the mirror and believe this, i will even be quite fair and give you 2 choices. #1....you are totally lost in coming up with a winning strategy and tactics so you hook your wagon to a cult leader that has his followers someday ready to think they will get rich my being extremely low on the ethics.

#2....you are even dumber than i can imagine..

i will check back to some quackjack thread in a few months and bet nothing has changed except for this.............many of quackjacks flock will be history as they will either blowup the account or run out of paper to trade on. see, ya later in summer quackerjackers. ..

 

[trader225]

It's running 2 to 1 against the method.
Even Jack, with his extensive Washington public relations experience, cannot spin this poll.

 

[Joab]

Quote from trader225:

It's running 2 to 1 against the method.
Even Jack, with his extensive Washington public relations experience, cannot spin this poll.

um ? ya !

That's a HUGE success considering 95% of traders loss money.

DUH