Quote from dbphoenix:
Taking every SP BO is probably not a wise course. At the very least you need some sort of trend filter. Otherwise you end up trading chop.
Not every SP BO will succeed, of course, but a strategy that kept you out of the last two days' gains bears re-examination.
Indeed this is true DB. It's important to ask why. I missed the short signal at 1380 on Weds. Yesterday I wasn't around for the short signal at 1348. So at this point it looks like the problem is not the method, but the dope behind the method.
I did not trade today but like every day I go to the chart and identify the best entry and exit of the day. Attached.
I also compared the "pivot breakout" method to the "pullback method", with the same trend filter (both were trend down all day today-- meaning take shorts only). At least today the quality of the entry was better with the pullbacks. But again the real issue is I have a harder time trading the breakouts. They make me feel uncomforable from the get-go because I feel like i'm chasing.
The pivot breakouts are marked with the short arrows on the bottom, pullbacks larger arrows on the top. Knowing how I trade, with the breakouts I would have
4 losses of at least 2 pts (x2) = -16
1 gain of 10 pts on one ctc,
and + 1 tick on the other = +10.5 TOTAL -5.5
For the pullbacks I would have
1 + 1 tick (x2) = +1.0
,and +8 pts on 1 ctc,
holding the other
over the weekend TOTAL +9.0 + an overnight holder
Side note, see how that 1336 support became resistance today.