Quote from iankotze:
IAN: "Well I think you are approaching this thing from a fantasy perspective. In reality this will be much harder than you think."
What other way is there to approach something you have not been involved with if not to approach it with examples and caution? I do not think the "screw it and just jump in" approach works out very well for many.
IAN: "First, it is easy to punch in some numbers in your calculator and work out favorable results. You are failing to see the problem with these generic numbers and that is that you will have to make it happen in a live and kicking market."
It's easier to just jump in blind and get your head cut off before you even begin to understand what is going on. Punching those numbers in a calculator give one a plan. The numbers are not optimized for favorable results, they simply spit out the outcome based on the data you input. If it is a good and worthwhile trade, take it. If not, pass and look for another. I am green to Futures, not trading.
IAN: "The products that trade at 12.5 dollar a tick will get you stopped out more often than not with your 5 tick stop loss. This is unless you are running a serious scalping system. But trust me if you want to do serious scalping TST is not the place to do it with those big commissions."
This is where patience and entry come in. If you enter correctly you will not need the stop unless the market reverses suddenly. I enter only on confirmation and momentum. If I need more room than my stop allows, the trade is not ready yet. I do not scalp so commissions are just part of the cost of doing business, not a profit devastating amount due to overtrading. A $40 commission is not a deterrent when profits are significantly higher. If $40 of commission wipes out your trading profits something is amiss.
IAN: "Every market has its own character and you need to get to know which market will work for you. What kind of system will you use, trend or range. Markets are all different in small ways but when trading futures you will come to know that these small differences are huge because you must be way more precise in your entry that you would have to trading stocks."
I am familiar with markets, psychology, price action and the good ol' crazy mindset of "Mr.Market". The calculator is just one aspect of my trading plan...not the plan in its totality.
IAN: "If you want to do the 1 trade a day with 5 ticks risk and 10 ticks profit I suggest you look at the 10 or 30 year bonds, even the ultra bond will most likely knock you out most of the time."
Again, the examples I used are just examples. I do not focus on one trade per day or 5 ticks down/10 ticks up. Once a market has been selected, I focus on risk percentages based on the market environment I have selected and my working capital. This will determine the ratio I use for risk to reward. I will trade more than once a day if the opportunities present themselves, but I am selective and do not just "shoot from the hip". However, if I have a profit and the day does not look to be offering much more, I will close up shop for the day rather than just "trading to trade" and give back what I have earned.
Not trying to be rude in any of that. Just trying to answer your questions and give a better idea of what I intend.
Thanks,
J.
Hope that helps