Out Today Market Making Scalping Manual

Status
Not open for further replies.
No - that would be a different game. Especially on interest rates, following spreaders etc. Time & Sales isn't used at all.

It does change based on the market state but it does not rely on stuff like mean reversion or anything else you'd relate to as a regular outright daytrader.

This is market making - it's a slightly different mindset.

Gary is good at what he does and what's delivered has a reason.

Videos would be quite pointless for a number of reasons - but the biggest is that people lean on them to bypass the process of getting experience. Mostly though - videos would just show you getting in and out, whereas the book covers the different facets you need to consider - some of which wouldn't even be on the screen.

Traders are incredibly lazy, most aren't even close to being serious. So we try and put people off as much as possible while still giving those willing to put in the work the things they need. We do the quarterly Q&A sessions (2 so far) to firm up any potential misunderstandings based on feedback.

It's going well - feedback has been good and at this point, I think the decisions Gary made have been validated as we see people having success with it.


"Videos would be quite pointless for a number of reasons - but the biggest is that people lean on them to bypass the process of getting experience. Mostly though - videos would just show you getting in and out, whereas the book covers the different facets you need to consider - some of which wouldn't even be on the screen.

Traders are incredibly lazy, most aren't even close to being serious. So we try and put people off as much as possible while still giving those willing to put in the work the things they need. We do the quarterly Q&A sessions (2 so far) to firm up any potential misunderstandings based on feedback."

I don't understand your rationale about videos. A picture is worth a 1000 words. Seeing is not only believing but also understanding. Words are useless in this business unless the instructor can demonstrate how it's done. I think Mr. Norden is avoiding the obvious: he's afraid he'll be caught in the quagmire of "it doesn't always work".

You're not "giving those willing to put in the work" what they really need. What they need is to learn from an instructor who's not afraid to demonstrate real time experience.

The traders that you assign as being "lazy" are probably more frustrated with the lack of proper instruction. Relegating the instruction process to 500 pages in a pdf is not instruction. It's a cover up.
 
Mostly though - videos would just show you getting in and out, whereas the book covers the different facets you need to consider - some of which wouldn't even be on the screen.

What type of information wouldn't be on the screen (DOMs, watchlist, quote board) that a trader would use to filter trades? Are there extra technology requirements?

I can't help but wonder if this is really market making. Tons of quoting up and down the book, pulling, playing the queue?

How do you handle toxic order flow, or is this not a huge issue because you are trading at slower times or in markets that do not go on too much price discovery?

LOL I wish you had more of a detailed FAQ on the jigsaw site for this offering.
Traders need to know what they are getting themselves into, and if it fits their style.
Why market making over what Axia teaches?
Axia seems to post examples of their trades, and they also appear to have some large traders.
Which style has a greater chance of a higher profit?
What type of volume are people doing with this market maker style?
 
I'm going to write my own Market Making Manual. I believe that I have learned enough to share ideas with the world. Mine is going to be around 10,000 words, and I might include images. I will likely only sell it for 99 cents with the Amazon advertising deal thingy. I will talk about my journey from a padawan to fighting my Jedi master Norden as the force awakens within me.
Peter will make an entrance as Obie-Wan Kenobi.

upload_2020-6-9_19-15-3.png
 
I’d like to make markets but I’d need rebates or even be paid for it. Usual retail commissions don’t allow for this kind of activity.
 
How do you handle toxic order flow

Usually when order flow is toxic (Adverse selection) then the liquidity disappears. No one’s willing to take it because spreads became tighter with all the competition. Since the business isn’t as profitable and monopolistic as before then the liquidity tends to disappear when we need it the most. Most of the time the market makers are just stepping in front the order flow imbalance. You can see it on the ES, when the delta is positive you’ll see more offers than bids.
 
This Norden person seems interesting but as others stated $1k for a manual that likely has nothing new in it and will likely say practice and watch the market essentially. A video of live market action would greatly increase interest and decrease the scam factor a tax return or audited brokers statement even better but even with that it just shows that the person selling and marketing somethig for people to buy themselves at least is able to make money..(which i guess is important) this doesnt guaranteed you will be able to pickup what he does or even is a good enough educator

Is this style of trading basically just the following?:

-Use the DOM
-Use executing market and correlated markets DOM to find which side of the market to lean on?
-Trade mostly Gold, Silver, Soybeans, Interest Rate products, but only indices at night or early morning when there is less volatility?

-Play the queue in slower/thicker markets, then deciding if you want to stay in as the queue works down and the correlations suggest that you lean on a bid or offer?
-Using Time & Sales to know which traders are 'in the game' looking out for bigger traders?
-Also, in some situations finding where the market is more in a 'market maker zone' such as a range where you can rely on with high probability mean reversion?
-When a market has heavy 'lean' for example towards the buy-side, continue to lean on bids until velocity slows down.
-Use those correlations, but pay attention to how things are trading in your market, and who is trading.
-Pay attention to how you are filled because this will let you know what to expect.

If the above is true, then a dude I talk to on Reddit and whose videos I use to watch on youtube told me how to do this for FREE! He took down most of his videos save for one, but what i posted is basically we talked about. I had about 30 conversations with him, and he just told me what he was working on and his thoughts on "manual market-making style scalping."

He said that he just figured it out for himself by reading a bunch of old math-heavy research papers on algo market-making, and tried to make what he learned work for a slower manual execution style of scalping that didn't really compete with the algos, although "the algos are always in the game when it makes sense for them to be."

He told me that in faster markets like ES/NQ/YM to rethink and reframe what the spread is. His precise words, "the spread is what you create based on where YOU place your bid/asks, not necessarily the inside bid and offer." Before he took down his videos, he said something similar while scalping YM for around 3-6 ticks/trade. He talked about "where to make your market, looking for back-and-forth action where you can easily flip out on the bid or ask."

That dude did more for my trading than anyone without charging a thing. Gary Norden doesn't share any trading videos, the NDA of his course might make it so that people who bought it are afraid to even give a review and $999 just for a what 60-page ebook? That is a risky product. What if you buy it and find out that it is junk, that the above what I posted is basically what it is?

That guy who use to make videos and who use to post on Reddit said he knows someone who paid Norden's full fee, the $3000 one and that student of Norden after 6 months didn't know how to trade the style.

Why can't Gary Norden just share a simple video? Is the style so simple that one video would give all the secrets? Why can't the $999 book have images in it to share some examples of what he looks for on the DOM? He is asking a lot of money just for some words. He generally seems like an honest dude, but this book seems like it isn't worth what he is asking. Does he go over video in the monthly sessions mentioned on the Jigsaw website?

One thing that Reddit dude said was that a lot of information on DOM/Price Ladder trading has come out because a lot of the techniques simply do not work any longer, and a lot of these former big shot prop traders have lost their edge. He said, that many educators are selling stuff that worked in 2005. He said something I won't share that was negative about another DOM scalper educator who charges a good amount of money to have ppl watch him trade, and what he said made sense.
 
This Norden person seems interesting but as others stated $1k for a manual that likely has nothing new in it and will likely say practice and watch the market essentially. A video of live market action would greatly increase interest and decrease the scam factor a tax return or audited brokers statement even better but even with that it just shows that the person selling and marketing somethig for people to buy themselves at least is able to make money..(which i guess is important) this doesnt guaranteed you will be able to pickup what he does or even is a good enough educator

One issue I have is figuring out who is the guide's intended audience. Is this a guide for price ladder (DOM) newbs. Is it for people who have price ladders skills, but not 'market making skills' and would someone who has put in the time to learn market making on their own be disappointed with the guide?

The biggest fear is that this is all just stuff that anyone who has worked hard on their own would have discovered.
 
The biggest fear is that this is all just stuff that anyone who has worked hard on their own would have discovered.
Market makers go for the bid/ask spread by placing limit orders in the book this isnt somethign that is difficult to get like with any strategy the issue will be execution. Thats why im guessing the book is basically a work hard and you will get it type of thing. My issue is that this likely isnt possible with our connections unless your sitting in the book for very long periods of time your queue will likely be last whenever price is near where you want to enter so you are basically always going against what price is currently doing getting out for 1 or 2 ticks while going for 1 or 2 ticks minus commissions seems like a losing strategy. $1k for a manual I've never seen a statement a live trading session or even a video with him analyzing the market I've only seen him bashing technical analysis and saying that only the current price matters. Im very suspicious of people who tout the i used to work on the floor in 2020 the way your trading is different you have no idea who is playing the orders if they are entries or exits. Its like that big money options trader ad that comes up on every trading youtube video i watch. If you watch Jigsaw youtube videos im sure most of that order flow type of stuff is there anyway why pay $1k to hear work hard and you to be a trader?
 
Last edited:
If you watch Jigsaw youtube videos im sure most of that order flow type of stuff is there anyway why pay $1k to hear work hard and you to be a trader?

I have always thought that the core of these techniques was shared in the following videos, just not fleshed out: (1) Scalping - The Read Deal (2) Getting Started in Scalping (3) Using Market Correlations in Day Trading. The rest is up for the trader to figure out.

Learning more evolved ideas around when/how to use the spread hasn't seemed to be shared much, but those conversations are out in the wild (Internet) so perhaps this manual is for lazy traders who haven't taken the time to do any research?

These replies also seemed to share a bit.

upload_2020-6-11_9-49-20.png


For people who have done their homework, I do not understand where the value exists.
I disagree with you about 1-tick trades. I've done these quite successfully since studying that reddit dudes DMs. Mostly in ZB, NKD, Silver, Soybeans, and sometimes ES when it is quiet early early mornng. I don't like ES.
 
I have always thought that the core of these techniques was shared in the following videos, just not fleshed out: (1) Scalping - The Read Deal (2) Getting Started in Scalping (3) Using Market Correlations in Day Trading. The rest is up for the trader to figure out.

Learning more evolved ideas around when/how to use the spread hasn't seemed to be shared much, but those conversations are out in the wild (Internet) so perhaps this manual is for lazy traders who haven't taken the time to do any research?

These replies also seemed to share a bit.

View attachment 230328

For people who have done their homework, I do not understand where the value exists.
I disagree with you about 1-tick trades. I've done these quite successfully since studying that reddit dudes DMs. Mostly in ZB, NKD, Silver, Soybeans, and sometimes ES when it is quiet early early mornng. I don't like ES.

lol that exchange is literally all there is the rest is up to you to get the instinct. Personalize help would be the edge in learning this but something tells me that for $1k that isnt part of the deal. I was looking at ES mostly since that will be the most likely contract traded by people yes ZB could work i think those offers and bids mostly stay and dont pull like they do in NQ and ES.

I like jigsaws product though i dont use it anymore because of the 1 product per market data thing bookmap contains more data though i really prefer the jigsaw DOM compared to bookmap but the visual of bookmap is much better. I think software companies really should stay away from pushing educators bookmap and Jigsaw are similar Jigsaw gives trading advise free thats better than most educators so does bookmap they have a free daily live market analysis and education for their customers.
You really tarnish your company a bit associating with educators. Bookmap has "pro webinars" and none of said pros ever analysis anything live its always replays and screenshots but will mention their training course.

Listening to the new interview and Gary says that he will never post his trading on youtube and that his training video will be different that the person thats being interviewed and the person interviewed said that you have to put in the work. So basically your getting basic information and its up to you in order to learn it. He is using the excuse that he doesnt want people copying his trading.

Clearly there are people that will buy it(probably people that are newer to purchasing orderflow stuff) I think people should lookup orderflow and market making strategy's before buying this simply look at jigsaws stuff. Queue position, correlation and momentum that is retail market making the rest is what he will tell you put in the work and save your money.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top