you actually made an excellent point yourself: It comes down to finding the strategies that work for you yourself. Writing options outright is in my opinion a terrible strategy, especially when one tries to make a living from that. Sooner or later the lightning strucks and you give all back and then some. When you want to use options to express a directional view then spreads are definitely the wrong choice. I find it funny how some guys say that almost nobody can pick direction but then they recommend i.e. spreads and list a whole lot of conditions that need to be met to make the spread position dominate others, performance wise. Isnt that contradicting? Again, each strategy has its place, but from what you wrote below I would also rather put on a outright call or put position. You can reduce size but thats more a function of your money and risk management than picking the right strategy. You could also play the skew by putting on a "risky" position which you could either run outright or initially delta hedged. The profit potential is however limited so is the risk vs an outright call or put position.
Quote from jsv416:
Iluvvol. Thanks for the thoughtful response. It took me a while to read your reply and fully digest it.
More about my trading. I trade S/R levels of stocks and etfs. Sometimes I use options to do this when the price of the underlying is expensive. When I did spreads I usually ended up kicking myself because I nailed a big winner but had limited my upside because of the spread. Yes the risk is limited in the spread but i can also limit my risk through position sizing. So I swore off spreads, but I keep hearing about traders applying spreads to this or that and wonder why the hell they would do that. Obviously, their trading style is different than mine and I should just stay away from what i dont understand.