This is a very educational thread, and I am enjoying it. I have a lot of experience not only personally utilizing the different methodologies described so vividly by you in your posts, but also working with successful traders who employ each of the different methodologies.
If it makes any difference to you, I started as a pure NYSE trader. I then added some Nasdaq stocks to my trading. This was (1993) seven years after I placed my first trade. One year later, Nasdaq stocks made about 40% of my trading. In 1995, Nasdaq made about 75% of my trading. This year, it has been about 92% Nasdaq and 8% for both NYSE and options.
The game has changed a lot over the years, but many things remain the same!
1. Risk Management
2. Risk Management
3. Risk Management
And of course, psychology.
I just finished reading Pit Bull (bought the book about 18 months ago and finally had free time to read it). I found it to be entertaining and easy to read and relate to. He talks a lot about having a system that matches your personality and style. But the true hidden treasure, the fifth element, that he had was a partner that was a soul-mate -- who balanced the energy, positive or negative, for him. His worst losing day was when his partner was not there.
So, it is all about YOU and what YOU are comfortable with. There is no MY way is better than YOUR way. In the book he refers to it as the "Who has the biggest #$%%"
The middle ground: A liquid volatile listed stock that trades like the Nasdaq. Hmmm ... I think I know one ... QQQ
Moral: Trade what works for you, but do not, under any circumstance, suffer from tunnel vision. Keep your mind open and learn about other strategies. Why? Because the market changes and your comfort level changes.
Now that I exposed myself to an argument that no one can possibly win, bring it on
Magna,
I kept my promise to my wife. One day to go. I am counting the minutes
Trade Smart!