One for the ages: I owe Etrade $106k, ouch.

You folks are so naive. This is just another Nigerian scam in disguise.

Think about it. Are we still stuck in the late 90s? Since the 2008 financial meltdown, ET and just about all other brokers in the industry have risk protocols in place to protect themselves in a situation like this. His position would have been liquidated once his account balance breached that protocol. (ie. once it reached $0.00).

Whether true or not, this is a good tale of OMGWTF! (And to note, almost 10% of the float was shorted so he is not alone in the Boat of Sudden and Extreme Pain.):

I owe Etrade $106k, ouch.

Hello to all you traders out there. I'm starting this page out of the recommendation of other traders in the community.

I hesitated on doing this but I literally owe Etrade $106,445.56 as of this moment what would you do if you were in my situation? I'll do whats needed and sell what I have to get them paid but if someone feels my pain and is willing to help out---who am I to say no?

If you don't want to donate I understand, at least read my story of what happened today and protect yourself from the same happening to you! This is a terrible lesson for me but if this helps just one person than I'm happy I wrote this.

I'm a fairly new trader, been trading since about March of this year. I have learned alot about the community and trading...well not enough about trading as you will soon hear.

I have a fairly small account, but its over PDT. As of this morning it was $37,000. I keep it small because I wanted to manage risk, the most I can afford to lose is what I have in the account....$37,000. When I get some profits I take them out of the account because I wouldn't want to lose more than $37k.

I was holding KBIO short overnight for what I thought was a nice $2.00 fade coming. At the close of the bell I saw the quote montage clear out and figured today there was no action after hours in the stock. So I went to my office for a long meeting. I got out of the meeting and saw a message from one of my buddys, he asked if I was ok since I was short KBIO....my heart dropped. "Shoot did I blow up my account, everything I worked for? I don't want to lose all $37,000 that would be terrible." ---It was much worse.

The stock was at $16 and my account was negative over 100k. I figured it was a mistake, Etrade would never let that happen, they must have cut the position when my account got to $0....nope. I immediately called them and they confirmed I still owned all the shares. He says that it got out of hand too fast for them to cover me, he says that all he can do right now is cover. I was devistated. I asked him to cover at $16 and he waited trying to find me a good exit. I told him to do it asap and the fill was around $18.50 avg.

At the moment not only is my $37k gone, but I now owe ETrade the negative balance of over $106k. I always knew I could blow up an account and I was financially able to "afford" to lose the $37k. Never in my wildest dreams did I imagine that Etrade would NOT have some sort of stop or circuit breaker in place that would automatically cut a position if the account went to $0.....how could they ever let it get to -$144k loss on a account that small! Also, why did I have to call them to find out what was going on, why did they not alert me or call me when it went neg???

I'm never one to ask for a handout and honestly I'm kinda not sure if I should post this but here we go. I'm sure it will cause lots of controversy on whether or not I deserve even a $1 donation but it doesn't hurt to ask. Anything you traders can do to help me get a little out of this hole would be a blessing for me. Anything donated will go 100% to simply paying Etrade some of this $106,445.56.

My plan moving forward is to liquidate mine and wife's 401k's and try work out a payment plan with Etrade. I'm also going to ask them to help out in some way...thats a longshot. I will pay them and be back trading....only with set stops this time. What an expensive lesson that was.

I hope my story helps someone else from the same.

Here are screenshots of the damage.
 
As someone else mentioned in another website, he could have just bought some puts. Other protection would be short the stock and buy calls to protect the position.

In futures, this is why I set stops and don't trade overnight.
 
You folks are so naive. This is just another Nigerian scam in disguise.

Think about it. Are we still stuck in the late 90s? Since the 2008 financial meltdown, ET and just about all other brokers in the industry have risk protocols in place to protect themselves in a situation like this. His position would have been liquidated once his account balance breached that protocol. (ie. once it reached $0.00).


Not being naive. I said it is likely a scam. But the price gapped up overnight -- there is nothing ET could do. Even IB doesn't usually do after-market liquidations, and they are the most responsive.
 
This is just wrong in so many ways. The guy shorts a biotech with a tiny float. Biotechs are known to have huge % moves . Anyone who trades them has to know they are by far the most volatile stocks out here. He shorts a 2.00 stock. Why bother? The news about them going under has been in the stock for a while. Risk reward in shorting a 2.00 stock is horrible. Especially some thin biotech. This guy, while probably a nice guy, really has no idea how equity trading works. He is blaming Etrade??? The news came out after the close. A lot of retail brokers don't monitor after hours trading. Also since when is it up to the broker to babysit a trader?

But the worst part is that he is actually out there asking the public to bail him out on a stock trade? Really? What about the guys who got obliterated in SHPG last year over night ? Should they all have go fund pages? How about the guys who bought ES pre-open on Aug 24th and had their accounts clobbered that morning? Let's set up some go fund pages for them.

I'm sorry for the guy but this is absolutely ridiculous. Etrade should go after him for all of the money. Not a dime less. Otherwise it sets a real bad precedent.

I don't think it is about the ability to trade after-hours --- If Etrade could trade AH, and that is a big IF that the prices are even "fair" after AH, and then the stock did not gap up at all, the investor can sue Etrade for false liquidation and it is hard for ET to prove it did the right thing, since the official market doesn't show those prints.
 
Not being naive. I said it is likely a scam. But the price gapped up overnight -- there is nothing ET could do. Even IB doesn't usually do after-market liquidations, and they are the most responsive.

IB will in fact auto-liquidate positions pre- and aftermarket. Also most brokerages will run a stress test on all open positions and they will force partial or complete liquidation just before the close of the market in case they feel the stock will run foul with their criteria of the test.

Most stocks collapsed during the 2008 financial meltdown. Almost all of the stocks were severely impacted on the day of the Flash Crash. To say that ET (or any other brokerage) will allow you to trade with reckless abandon, even if the stock in question is only $2, would be an admission of utter ignorance. I don't think they're that stupid.
 
This is just wrong in so many ways. The guy shorts a biotech with a tiny float. Biotechs are known to have huge % moves . Anyone who trades them has to know they are by far the most volatile stocks out here. He shorts a 2.00 stock. Why bother? The news about them going under has been in the stock for a while. Risk reward in shorting a 2.00 stock is horrible. Especially some thin biotech. This guy, while probably a nice guy, really has no idea how equity trading works. He is blaming Etrade??? The news came out after the close. A lot of retail brokers don't monitor after hours trading. Also since when is it up to the broker to babysit a trader?

But the worst part is that he is actually out there asking the public to bail him out on a stock trade? Really? What about the guys who got obliterated in SHPG last year over night ? Should they all have go fund pages? How about the guys who bought ES pre-open on Aug 24th and had their accounts clobbered that morning? Let's set up some go fund pages for them.

I'm sorry for the guy but this is absolutely ridiculous. Etrade should go after him for all of the money. Not a dime less. Otherwise it sets a real bad precedent.


Everyone is blaming others and trying to get a free handout. Its a sad commentary on today's society.
 
IB will in fact auto-liquidate positions pre- and aftermarket. Also most brokerages will run a stress test on all open positions and they will force partial or complete liquidation just before the close of the market in case they feel the stock will run foul with their criteria of the test.

Most stocks collapsed during the 2008 financial meltdown. Almost all of the stocks were severely impacted on the day of the Flash Crash. To say that ET (or any other brokerage) will allow you to trade with reckless abandon, even if the stock in question is only $2, would be an admission of utter ignorance. I don't think they're that stupid.

Can anyone give an example of IB auto-liquidating pre-market for an account only holding equities? I have never heard of this.

Yes, all brokers with portfolio margin do a test periodically and liquidate during the trading day or close.

I see you picked up Obama's choice. Either I have to allow the broker to liquidate my position at random prices eg. -50% pre-market, or I must be trading with reckless abandon. I often see ask prices of 9999.99 for many stocks pre-market, so why not autoliquidate all accounts with short positions?
 
Also, if the story is true, he could just file bankruptcy. I googled and 401k's are protected by bankruptcy. It is negligence on Etrade's part to not have auto margin calls even in after hours so he is not liable for the loss beyond what he had in the account if he files for protection.
 
Back
Top