Quote from mgookin:
All of this is a prime (no pun intended) example of why the banks' finances are in a shitload of turmoil.
Take that $1 house sold where it cost the bank $10k in slush monies just to unload it. If they were unloading it, then they had paper (a mortgage) on it. Add the $10k to the value of the mortgage at time of foreclosure, and that's how much their balance sheet took a shit on this one property.
As holder of a mortgage, the holder has choices. If payments are late or not paid, they can either
foreclose and sell it (and look what happens) or
they can work something out with the current owner who is late on their payments, or
they can foreclose and sit on it.
Many banks are choosing to foreclose and sit on properties. If the mortgage balance is $200k, then it's a $200k asset on the books as long as it's sitting. If they unload it for a net of $50k, then they have to find $150k on their balance sheet to make up for it just to stay solvent.
Once they choose to pay an attorney $5k to foreclose, take over maintenance, property taxes, lawn mowing, local ordinance liabilities (code enforcement is what its called here), risk of act of god (flood/ fire/ etc.), vandalism, etc. they have to be nuts to take all this on.
Recognizing they (banks) are willing to do short sales, what I don't understand is why their greed is hurting their balance sheets. If Johnny owes $500k on his mortgage on a now $300k home and his income was cut in half because of the current depression, then why won't a bank work with him to prevent foreclosure. They will tell Johnny "as long as its not you, your friends or your family we will entertain a short sale." So now instead of mitigating the $200k descrepency such that each party eats $100k, the bank plays hardball and ends up getting a net of $225k on a $500k note. That's pretty stupid.
During the Great Depression the few banks who survived worked things out with property owners. They told the farmers to keep working the land and earn what you can and if you earn enough, give us some money, and if you don't, then just hang in there until times get better. It will all work out in the end.