Quote from Mav88:
Ricter, all arguments about groups/race are statistical in nature.
Individual stories are just that, anecdotes. I know a few too, but it's way too few. I care about what they accomplish as a group.
Being in science and engineering I see first hand the sad state of american blacks. It's so bad that 8 (yes only 8) blacks make the news for wanting to create 'tech' startups. I put in quotes because I don't think twitter type ripoffs are tech.
http://money.cnn.com/galleries/2011/technology/1107/gallery.newme_accelerator/?iid=HP_LN
Honestly, I wish it were not true because I am cheering for america. As I see it now though, blacks as a group will never contribute soon in other than music and sports. At a time when finances are imploding this is going to cause even more problems.
Which is why I can say, statistically speaking, the black engineer and his family will succeed in following generations. So, if he can do this, others can, too.
Did he get where he is thanks to affirmative action? If yes, then affirmative action can work. Or if it wasn't affirmative action, then was it simply his own efforts? If it was his own efforts, then the black man can succeed. Either way, these anti-diversity arguments are crap, and the statistics cannot help us envision a future.