With all the data available on a 1-minute chart, you can cherry-pick screenshots for any strategy. I'm sure Stochastics and MACD "call" tops and bottoms sometimes, too. That doesn't mean they give anyone a consistent, long-term edge. You'd have to track every trade using a certain strategy over a meaningful time period and give the full results.
I still haven't been able to exactly discern my human intuition that keeps me on the right side of PnL. I need to figure that out.

