Oil : Oversold Indicators

I was with you right up to the point you said swing trading is better then scalping, then I got off the train fast! I don't know how long you been swing trading, but I can tell you right now the market is too volatile to swing trade, Nothing is as it was 3 years ago or longer. The only way you can swing trade this market is if you have a large amount of money to move around the board. You ether take a positions in the morning and get out at the end of the trading day or scalp. When I first got into trading I make a good living swing trading, now I wouldn't swing trade on a sim account with paper money. The HFT have learn how to go after hedge funds and swing trader's account. don't thing they are going after intro day traders only anymore, that's old news. the big money now is hitting hedge funds and swing trading stops just after or before the market opens. IMO

Ya scalping is appropriate for a newbie...

Excellent way to learn.
 
I'm relatively new to trading, but I would like to start tracking the price of oil futures in order to understand when they are overbought and oversold. I have been trying to use the bollinger bands, RSI, etc on the CLH16 March futures. Can anyone tell me if there is a more effective way to do this, or if I am on the right track using these indicators?
Thanks for any feedback
%%
I like futures for price + volume, LouisN;
NOT to learn how to trade-thats the worst way.
As far as RSI;
no thanks.Some people like stopped clocks, because they're right 2 times per day.

Dont try this @ home but one advantage of WAAAAAy to much leverage learning; you may remember the lesson.But wisdom is profitable to direct-NOT a prediction
 
Oh come on don't be SO stupid - no one with any sense will not use indicators.
Some people know how to use them and many others don't. What do you use? Flipping a coin?

For day trading I use my own intelligence with direct observation of price action, naked charts, MTFA. No indicators are ever used for real time trading although charts are annotated with straight lines. It is very important to be aware of the timing of market announcements as no indicator will be of any use whatsoever when volatility kicks in and prices yo yo back and forth. When I started trading in the distant past I did go down the usual naive route of using indicators, it didn't take me long to realize that it was foolish to do so.

In the past I've swing traded stocks holding positions for periods of days to months. As part of an off line scanning process of a large number of equities, RSI and Stoch indicators were used in the filter to produced a manageable set of equities that could be viewed by eye to decide whether to trade them or not. So apart from using indicators as part of a scanning process they were not used to make trading decisions.

Seriously, flipping a coin could vastly improve results for some losing traders, of which most are. At least results should get closer to breakeven rather than losing badly. For those traders who are not objective in making their decisions, flipping a coin to decide to make the next trade long or short and then waiting for the setup to occur would mitigate the tendency of some to fight the market.
 
Thanks for the feedback. I have no plans to trade futures or to even buy energy stocks/ETFs in the near future. I'm just wanting to learn how to understand these things a bit better by using some of the more widely used indicators. I try to keep up with rig count and other data, but using the technicals is something I am still trying to figure out.
 
CL futures is inappropriate for the inexperienced. (well, most all futures are actually)

Geopolitical risks, contango, market manipulation, volatility, leverage are a recipe for disaster for the naive.

If you are serious about learning to trade, start with longer term "Swing" and as you become more adept, then and only then slowly lower your time frames. Stay away from CL, GC and focus more on Index's, SPY or QQQ are a good place to start.

And as an FYI Oscillators, Bands, RSI, Stocks, MACD, etc... aren't going to give you an edge...

Anything else and you just become another "feeder fish"
View attachment 161825
Listen to this guy. I have been trading for almost 8 years now, and CL is a whole another beast.
Everything he just said, is golden.
 
For day trading I use my own intelligence with direct observation of price action, naked charts, MTFA. No indicators are ever used for real time trading although charts are annotated with straight lines. It is very important to be aware of the timing of market announcements as no indicator will be of any use whatsoever when volatility kicks in and prices yo yo back and forth. When I started trading in the distant past I did go down the usual naive route of using indicators, it didn't take me long to realize that it was foolish to do so.

In the past I've swing traded stocks holding positions for periods of days to months. As part of an off line scanning process of a large number of equities, RSI and Stoch indicators were used in the filter to produced a manageable set of equities that could be viewed by eye to decide whether to trade them or not. So apart from using indicators as part of a scanning process they were not used to make trading decisions.

Seriously, flipping a coin could vastly improve results for some losing traders, of which most are. At least results should get closer to breakeven rather than losing badly. For those traders who are not objective in making their decisions, flipping a coin to decide to make the next trade long or short and then waiting for the setup to occur would mitigate the tendency of some to fight the market.

I totally agree with you most newb's do better flipping a coin and why casinos do so well as they leave it to player to make a choice and choices are often wrong. I further believe and advise newbs to learn charting first few years as they don't have a clue what price should be doing when patterns develop, but once you have develop Trading plan and including money management rules, I see no problem using indicators as a way to quickly see from across the room what market doing. I have used indicators since I started in late seventies and doing by hand, but I was lucky then that I had to chart by hand as well. I just find indicators easier for me and at my age anything easier is a plus, you get older and reflexes slow down, you don't realize as years goes by the body slowly starts to hurt by sitting and yet walking around will hurt too, LOL

I am glad for you that you can trade with just charts, everyone has there ways of trading for a living. I think way too many believe that indicators are going to predict the future and that is not what they were designed to do, they are to indicate the past and just like price charts, they show us what has already happened and based on our knowledge we have developed rules for entry.

Good trading to you.
 
CL futures is inappropriate for the inexperienced. (well, most all futures are actually)

Geopolitical risks, contango, market manipulation, volatility, leverage are a recipe for disaster for the naive.

If you are serious about learning to trade, start with longer term "Swing" and as you become more adept, then and only then slowly lower your time frames. Stay away from CL, GC and focus more on Index's, SPY or QQQ are a good place to start.

And as an FYI Oscillators, Bands, RSI, Stocks, MACD, etc... aren't going to give you an edge...

Anything else and you just become another "feeder fish"
View attachment 161825
looking for a squeeze to happen here into contract expiration as high as $32
%%
Donchian channel is still down-trending, if you like indicators.
SPY + QQQ are much better to learn on, more liquid, that is when you close a position.LOL

If i had to use a RSI + i dont have to use RSI; $61 dollars is an important level on weekly 14 days RSI, modified.Another reason I dont like RSI, that level is important on crude light, without RSI.......................................................................................... IBD uses put call ratio; fine, that does not mean i want another indicator.LOL-at my comment.NOT laughing @ anyone .
 
Back
Top