This will probably make you angry and cause you to lash out at me, but that's okay. Nothing personal, or maybe this is, but that doesn't sound truthful. This is your thread that you started. Why didn't you post the fact that you dumped your oil on the open yesterday? I know you said you were going to but why didn't you say you had until now? Makes it sound a bit sketchy. You call other people on their stuff in these forums so I'm questioning you. What it is. I don't know you and maybe you're being honest, but I've been doing this for some time and see lots of traders say similar things after a move goes against them which would have made them look bad. Next time maybe it would be good to post your exit and profits or losses to let others know how the trade went. I mean you're the one making the call. My thoughts.
Hey man, it's nothing personal. You may be a great guy and honest as they come. Like I say I don't really know you. You can post your calls if you like or not. Like my post I just posted said, it's more about the timing. Not talking about hand holding. Something maybe others are interested in but not me. I do my own trades. If you choose to share your trades that's cool. I think that's great. But you must admit the term "short term bottom" does imply more than one day. At least most people would see it that way. If you're going to make these calls maybe you should say how you did, where you exited, etc. like on the one you made $500k on. Just a thought. You've been around too and have seen other traders say things after the fact. You did mentionn in the P&L thread a week or so ago you had lost $295k in a couple of days, so that definitely does show honesty there.
I don't really want to be on bad terms with anyone here but just call it like I see it as do you. Peace. 