Quote from AAAintheBeltway:
I agree with you in part, but I think you're way underestimating the degree of difficulty in what you're proposing. First, the anchor baby concept is not a law that can be overturned by congress. It's a Supreme Court decision that will either have to be reversed by the Court or reversed by a Constitutional Amendment. I do agree with you that the current interpretation is wrong and not what was intended, but changing it will be damn hard.
As for providing services to illegals, you might recall that California passed a referendum a few years back mandating exactly that. No freebies for illegals. A federal judge promptly declared it unconstitutional and California did not appeal, obviously because the democrats then in charge(Gray Dvais administration) agreed with the decision. That decision is not binding on other states however, and there are ways California could get around it if they wanted to. For example, they could pass another referendum, just like Chicago( and Washington, DC) did with their gun laws that were declared unconstitutional.
Yes, it would be difficult, if not impossible to do anything of substance about the Anchor baby law. I still think it's an issue that needs to be addressed in a very public way. I would guess the majority of Americans do not understand how the 14th Amendment is being perverted to allow this Anchor baby crap to continue. We need to call out those that support it, and give the people an opportunity to vote them out.
If we do not take away the incentives to come here, they'll keep coming. The other alternative is gunning them down at the border. Much as I'd like to see that we all know it ain't going to happen.
This situation is what has me so negative about our country. 20 million illegals and more coming every day is simply not sustainable, and will create a level of poverty accross the board for tens of millions of Americans, the like of which we have never experienced. It will make the Great Depression look like a cake walk.
