Originally posted by def
knight,
i don't have time to read all your posts in depth this morning but i would like to correct a few of your statements.
1. you say i don't trade - wrong: I just don't trade in the states. I am responsible for the asian trading for timberhill. i used to trade in the US from upstairs and traded on the floor in HK. i've overseen millions of trades - if you like to think i/we know nothing about options trading, so be it.
2. volumes on the amex are sliding, they are rising on the ISE and most other electronic venues around the world. there is a reason for this - price/time priority and a level playing field.
3. your assumptions regarding how timber trades and why there were layoffs are completely off base. w/o fully knowing the ins and outs of US policy I suspect that the move on the AMEX is reflective of allocating resources to where things are trading.
this was a nice discussion until you started talking about things you are clueless about. how about trying to get it back on track.
Def,
Since you have never traded on a US exchange let me enlighten you - Anyone that has, knows what your firm is all about - throw guys into a pit and have them do what the computer tells them. You may have convinced this day trading audience that you are an authority on trading options, but any floor trader knows differently. I will go a step further and say that I think a head clerk from any of the larger trading companies (Susquahenna, Wolverine, Knight, Hull, etc) has a better understanding of trading derivatives than any of your traders.
The logic of my questioning your comprehension of derivatives trading is in my posts - read them.
Volumes are sliding everywhere, including equity markets, and it's due to a RECESSION - all you have to do is read a newspaper to know that. I'm sure that a US newspaper is available to you in Hong Kong.
Your firm (and many other firms, including mine) have laid off people and plan more layoffs if the current market conditions prevail. You did not reallocate your traders, you let them go and the individuals that I know on the AMEX are concerned that they will be next.
I don't know why I'm even bothering to continue this discussion with you. You are incapable of adknowledging truths that any floor trading personnel will verify. Even your own post is gibberish - How can you know that I am off base if you don't know the ins and outs of US policy?
My advise to you is:
Start telling the truth.
Update yourself on the current US economy and market conditions.
Subscribe to a daily US financial publication.
Limit your dialogue to subjects that you are familiar with.
Maybe then we can have an honest, constructive, mutually educational and "nice" discussion.
The Knight