I agree on the ledger. I think the fixed supply is what will kill bitcoin.
of the 25mm bitcoin, like half is with satoshi and a half of the remaining is in landfills. A proper currency can’t work like That.
In some ways I do tend to agree that a currency has to increase with an increase in production, or maybe an increase in population, or I'm not sure what. If it doesn't, then you have more and more people chasing fewer and fewer dollars. So more dollars have to be made available.
Bitcoin is a fixed supply, but not until 2140 or so. Right now, every 10 minutes another 6.25 coins are created, and they go to the miner that creates the next block. They are doing real work that cannot be faked, just like gold miners are doing real work to get gold out of the ground. But when Powell just prints up a trillion dollars with no input of effort and sprinkles it first all over the rich people, which only makes stuff more expensive for the lower classes, I have a huge problem with that. (Keep in mind that 1 bitcoin is divisible into 100 million parts, called a satoshi, so there isn't really a shortage of coins. I'm not suggesting that I will one day buy bubble gum for 1 satoshi.... we can use government issued currencies for that. But we can very easily treat bitcoin as savings, and exchange for fiat when we need to. Just like you would with a gold bar today.)
So maybe a fixed supply isn't most ideal, but its a heck of a lot better than an unlimited supply. If you ever came across Jeff Booth, he has a book called The Price of Tomorrow. His main thesis is that as technology advances, it leads to a deflationary world where things should be getting cheaper. But given our monetary system based on debt and an ever expanding supply of dollars, its at direct odds with the direction that technology is moving. So you have these two systems battling it out. Its quite the interesting idea.
The idea that even 2% inflation is a goal baffles me. Why should we lose money every year? Its only to supports a failed system. The banking system worked just fine before fractional reserve banking came along. Inflation is a hidden tax, and I would much rather see the tax labelled for what it is, rather than accepting a forever inflating money supply as a way to reduce government debt.
So honestly, bitcoin is necessary in order to provide another way forward. There is simply no way right now to save the debt based system, no matter how much Powell tries with interest rate rises and the appearance of sound monetary policy now with their keep interest to tame inflation. If you're over 300lbs, the only solution is exercise and reducing caloric intake so that your expenditure is higher than your intake. And you need to do this for not only months, but the rest of your life. You can never go back to eating more than you burn if you want maintain a healthy weight once you get there. Our system will never have a balanced budget or a reduction in the debt. Its a 400lbs obese man who cannot take any steps necessary in order to reduce his weight. The end is guaranteed death, maybe via a sudden heart attack.