Ninja Trader or Trade Maven

teeoff · Jan 14, 2005

Quote from ForrestGump:

Negative.

There are several FCM's offering Ninja with non-PATS feeds. Open E Cry has by far the best setup. Other I.B's (e.g. Alaron I.B's ) should also look into this kind of setup. With a good feed, Ninja is hard to beat.

Cheers.

Edit: I inadvertently typed Transact instead of Open E Cry. Sorry.

BTW MB Trading also offers it with a non-PATS feed.

Thanks!

Truff · Jan 14, 2005

Quote from teeoff:

According to Ninja Trader, I cannot use Transact. That is who I currently have an account with. I was advised I would need to open an account with another broker. Transact has confirmed this as well. I really do not want to open another account. Trade maven supports Transact but I am more concerned about the order entry platform than the broker at this point.

If your concerned with the order execution the try CQG. Their Data feeds are second to none

fb5728 · Aug 27, 2005

I have A/C with the Trade station and I do not like to open another account with any broker aty this time. What choice do i have ? Ninja or Trade Maven ?

Thanks

Sam

shadowpug · Aug 27, 2005

Quote from fb5728:

I have A/C with the Trade station and I do not like to open another account with any broker aty this time. What choice do i have ? Ninja or Trade Maven ?

Thanks

Sam

No choice. TradeStation does not provide an API for products like NinjaTrader or TradeMaven to connect through.

MacroEvent · Aug 28, 2005

trademaven through transact futures is an excellent set-up -- i do some of my trading through them and i have had nothing but great reliability and very solid customer service.

volente_00 · Aug 28, 2005

I use Trademaven and love. It is constantly being improved and they are always adding useful tools.

traderdon56 · Aug 28, 2005

Yep, I have to agree that TM with the transact feed is very good. I get mine through Proactive futures.

Don-

quintrix · Aug 28, 2005

Quote from volente_00:

I use Trademaven and love. It is constantly being improved and they are always adding useful tools.

Agreed!

I tried Ninja with Global Futures and I've had a lot of problems

(order filled..in reality not filled!!...losing money)

Now I am very very satisfied with Trade Maven/Transact

Q.

saico · Aug 28, 2005

Quote from ForrestGump:

Negative.

There are several FCM's offering Ninja with non-PATS feeds. Open E Cry has by far the best setup. Other I.B's (e.g. Alaron I.B's ) should also look into this kind of setup. With a good feed, Ninja is hard to beat.

OpenEcry uses Pats for Ninja

MacroEvent · Aug 28, 2005

PATS is a feed to stay FAR AWAY from --- not even good for one lot trading --- HAHAHAHA!

Transact has rock solid data/quote feed and that is a MUST for trading any size.