Quote from mauzj:
Hi,
I've been trading with Oanda (real cash) for a couple of months. I am exclusively using technical analysis and risk 0.5% per trade. My planned holding period is just a few days. I do all charting on Sunday, place my orders, and then let the trades go.
The problem is that I'm down 2% and keep on losing. What would be the next best step in my education? Should I start learning fundamentals/economics? If so, could anyone recommend any good books or websites?
Thanks in advance,
Mauzj.
Hello people.
I just read this thread, and decided to contribute my 2 c.
First let me thank you Patrick for kind word, but lets not make my trading example for others. I just put my thoughts, others may take it as they wish. But thank you.
Mauzj:
- You've been trading real money from the start - and already applied fantastic risk management: you say your risk is 0.5%/trade - impressive number. But if may I ask, what's the avg target/profit per trade? try to keep this ratio (risk/reward) as high as possible. My avg ratio is standing on1:3, what's yours? keep that in mind.
- Your drawdown of 2% is nothing - 4 trades to loose in raw is regular happening for trader. I had 5 in raw this month before recovered, and in +16% MTD. That's another question: risking 0.5%, what kind of returns are you generating? Bcos risk and gain per trade, and consequently the overall performance depends on leverage used. I use 1:4, and risk in avg 2.6% a trade, but if I used 1:1, I would risk almost as much as you do, but returns would be 4 times less as well (well, the good side is that drawdown would be 4 times less as well

). But it depends on investors will to risk and profit, so generally its not question of what's % you risk per trade, but on what kind of leverage you risk that %...ok, little off the topic here, sorry.
- you trade longer time positions, and I think its best way on forex - at least that's what I think and that's what works for me (for someone else, scalping may be the way, 100%). Holding positions is what most of big players do as well, but as I said - its matter of what works for each individual.
- IMO, if you use TA, and you're good with it - no need in FA, I trade without even knowing what news/announcements are do to come out today - I don't look at economic calendar. And if I occasionally do look - its only of curiosity and not for trading purposes. Same on all kind of economic related articles.
- Way to go - analyzing market on Sunday. I do it every Sunday to determine strategy for coming days, and maybe for whole week - depends. I post my commentary (here and on moneytec) each Sunday before market opening, and I think its very useful to practice such analysis.
I saw suggestion here for you to keep journal of your trades - I agree, its very useful. I began trading in 1997, and started running journal only by the end of 2000. I consider all the time I didn't run journal as lost time for me. Extremely useful if you know how to benefit from it.
I also saw post here that forex is not for beginners...well, what market IS? high leveraged? Look at Mauzj - he's relatively new to forex, but is risking 0.5%. I don't know what's the avg stop used here, but even if its only 10 pips, its maximum 1:5 used here. (I think its much less leveraged, bcos I doubt its 10 pips stop)...so no, I disagree. And then, forex is as good as it gets for technical analyst...possibly best trending market, so for longer term traders like Mauzj, its even better market.
Best Regards,
Rezo