Newbies listen ! My Story w/ lessons

Quote from Daal:

I'm not worried about their success. I'm afraid a ton of them are either full of it or are lucky. ET poster IronFist did a few tests on the 'Daytrading 2.0' thread guy and found his system was not profitable, anekdoten doesnt understand the basic fundamentals of the market he trades yet claims to have had 7 losing days scalping the ES in 2007
I'm seeing a number of studies showing many TA patterns does not work yet you post here and people get all defensive and claim 'you are not trading it right', this is a recipe for getting fooled by randomness through selective reporting of people 'suceeding' using the pattern or selective reporting of 'ways' the pattern work

You better be careful with the material Anek has posted in ET. I approached him on IRC Othernet but most important I have talked to his gang. The guy trades nothing like what his AHG journal described. In fact, he's all about catching tops and bottoms. Be warned, his journal might have had bad intentions to begin with. Nice guy but a very ruthless trader.

ESD
 
Quote from Arnie Solovjovs:

Gentlemen Please.... There have been references to using price patterns, EMAS Volume and then having the candle-s confirm the trade. Where can one get this info to study? Thank You
http://www.trading-naked.com/Articles_and_Reprints.htm
 
Quote from wiesman02:

[
1) you'll never make it as a newbie trader if you rely on this as your only income source. Psychology is an a$$hole.

......wrong, most people lose becuase they have other sources of income. so they think loss is ok, and they keep losing. look at <<the market wizard>>, like baldwin, he quited job with $38k, and ready to roll, in half year, he got his first $1 million. the most important is people do not treat it seriously, they treat it as a hobby.
commitment is the key, do not take a try and see attitude is the key, must tell yourself: I must win and I must survive. then no matter whatever challenge, most people will prosper!

2) Trading the ES is tempting, high leverage, low capital start-up, but it is indeed VERY hard to trade. Like i said, there's only a few times per week that there are high probability setups. (some posters will disagree with me, kudos to you if you have a system with more setups, i have not found one yet).

ES is hard to trade, that is true since too many participants there. you can trade NQ or something else. I rearely trade ES. I trade crude or t-bonds, gold, natural gas, individual stocks with news, I switch around. I look for neat things to do. avoid the hard thing, do those easy things. most people do not understand how to avoid their shortcomings and work on their strength, they work on their shortcomings and avoid their strength, what a joke. lots of penny stocks is very tradable and can produce very good returns (they have nice patterns).




3) Not having a mentor is a recipe for disaster. its very tough to know what to look for, and what not to look for. Not having a mentor can take YEARS more on the learning curve, while a mentor can give it to u in 3 months or so if you listen.

kind of accept that. true. I struggled two years, then got some sense of it.

4) this is definitely not a get rich scheme. I'll be up $ in '09, but its not enough to live on..... Soon though

it is a get rich quick scheme. the key is you need first sharp your skills or graduate from the market, or you first need get the key. that takes time or money. most regular 8~5 job will not get you 7digits or 8 didgits. money earning is sensational or improtional to time spent or efforts involved, jus mouse click.

5) If you are not confident in your setups, you wont let winners ride. A lot of guys say newbies don't let winners ride..... Well its b/c they havent a clue if it is gonna reverse on them. Having a tried and true system makes letting winners ride very very easy. [/B]

people weigh loss more than gain, a $500 gain is less important than $500 loss, that is human nature. there is scientific proof. if you lost $500, your emotion is higher compared to $500 gain. that is why people cut profit quick. even professional ones, I know champion trader martin schwartz cut profits very quick, he admitted he loves to listen to the cash regester ring.

there is no tried or true system. market changes, you need learn to adapt.
 
Quote from Martinghoul:

Can I just ask the OP one question (and note that I don't mean to offend)?

You address your post to 'Newbies', implying you're not one of them.

Given that you have been trading for less than 2 years, what would you call yourself?

This was my first thought, then I skipped the rest of the post and went straight to the responses.
 
Quote from Martinghoul:

Can I just ask the OP one question (and note that I don't mean to offend)?

You address your post to 'Newbies', implying you're not one of them.

Given that you have been trading for less than 2 years, what would you call yourself?

perhaps my title should have read "Novice Traders Listen"

Indeed I am probably still considered a 'newbie' to some traders that have been in this biz for 10 years +, but I feel I have gotten past the 'probabtionary status' that the term 'novice' implies.
 
Quote from wiesman02:

perhaps my title should have read "Novice Traders Listen"

Indeed I am probably still considered a 'newbie' to some traders that have been in this biz for 10 years +, but I feel I have gotten past the 'probabtionary status' that the term 'novice' implies.

It really doesn't matter because there wasn't anything confusing about your opening statement to prompt someone to say it doesn't make sense.

My main point in this thread is that the S&P 500 Emini ES futures is a trading instrument that's well played by the professional traders (e.g. institutions). To compete with them you need a lot more than just a good trade signal although a few others in this thread strongly believe it's all that you need which is ironic because if you review their own message posts elsewhere here at ET...they too believe that there's no magical or voodoo indicator or pattern reaping consistent profits all by itself (e.g. they use words like money management, fundamentals, capitalization, position size management, FED actions et cetera).

Further, I think one of the most ignored component to successfully trading the S&P 500 Emini ES futures is market experience. However, some traders equate market experience to only screen time. It's more than screen time. It's an understanding of what really impacts the price action of the Emini ES futures to enable a trader's ability to adapt whenever the price action changes...a change that occurs many times every year since it's birth.

There's no shortcuts, no crystal ball, no magical indicator, no voodoo pattern...there's just a good trading plan and most traders don't have such which is why the S&P 500 Emini ES futures is tough for newbie or veteran traders. Simply, until a trader puts all those pieces together, it'll be a trader that will not be able to compete consistently with the pros except for a few lucky trading durations (days, a few weeks or few months). Lucky stuff that often encourages a trader to think they've found the holy grail single component.

By the way, other well played trading instruments by professionals is Oil, Gold, Treasuries.

I'm now done with this thread.

Mark
 
Quote from wiesman02:

For all you newbies that want to get into a career in trading, listen up. This was my personal experience so far. Read my story, and then read the points I will make. You've heard them before, but you don't want to listen b/c you think you are different, and it doesnt apply to you.


Well lets see, I started fulltime in Febuary of '08, trading stocks, but very very quickly switched over to futures. Lost a lot of $, but learned an invaluable amount of knowledge through one or two great people.

Trading as your sole source of income is pretty much impossible as a beginner. Kodos to anyone thats done it. I was living at home with my parents, and had a big nest egg saved in the bank, and I was still feeling pressured to perform. That resulted in not being patient and taking as much as 20 trades per day in the ES. Clearly i hadn't a bloody clue.

Fast forward 9 months later and I'd just finished getting mentored by a really good trader. Studied charts constantly after getting 3 months of mentoring by him. Pretty much opened my eyes to a lot of things, and set me on the right path for success. After that 9th month though, I'd lost a lot of $, and was very stressed out over the fact that I couldn't control my emotions. Pyschology was kicking my ass. Couldnt let winners ride, yet I had an uncanny ability to see PA once I was done being mentored.

8 months ago I landed a sweet job where I work either evening shift or morning shift pulling in $40's base + OT. Immediately, it had an affect on my trading. I began being more patient, waiting for that great setup. I no longer rely on this as a form of income, so I'm not 'looking' for trades. I'm waiting for a setup! My winning trade percentage broke 50%, then 60% ! Thats not to say I dont still have problems letting the winners run (emotions), but I'm doing better.

Soon, I was only taking about 5-8 trades per week max. Shit, some days I dont even had setups, and I sit at the computer twiddling my thumbs waiting for a trade that doesn't show up. In this environment, I've seen my frequency of setups dip as low as 2 or 3 per week. I've had to resort to looking at a 60 min chart for some trades. But thats OK ! When the setups do happen, I am very confident in my trade, and am not so quick to 'cut a winner short' as I know the potential if everything pans out.

Its my firm belief that if you are looking for high probability setups in the ES.....well, if you are looking to beat the ES, there's really only a few really good setups that arise per week. Back in '08, b/c of the volatility that # doubled. But if you're looking for a high probability of winners, you need to be patient. The setups will happen, but not nearly as numerous as I'd like. You can always scalp your way to death, and maybe you'll get lucky, but it won't last.

Some people say that price action is random, and there's no predicting it. With all the programs hedging, scalping, etc etc, people say its almost impossible to make sense out of direction. Well, to some degree, thats true. There's a lot of chop that makes it rough. My TF of choice is the 15 min charts. Every now and then, you'll see PA repeat itself from past occurances, and you say "hey, I recognize that pattern", and its easy money. but if you're a noob, not having a lot of screen time, you won't know it or see it.

My point in this post.....its been reiterated a million times, but I figured I'd share my background.


1) you'll never make it as a newbie trader if you rely on this as your only income source. Psychology is an a$$hole.

2) Trading the ES is tempting, high leverage, low capital start-up, but it is indeed VERY hard to trade. Like i said, there's only a few times per week that there are high probability setups. (some posters will disagree with me, kudos to you if you have a system with more setups, i have not found one yet)

3) Not having a mentor is a recipe for disaster. its very tough to know what to look for, and what not to look for. Not having a mentor can take YEARS more on the learning curve, while a mentor can give it to u in 3 months or so if you listen.

4) this is definitely not a get rich scheme. I'll be up $ in '09, but its not enough to live on..... Soon though

5) If you are not confident in your setups, you wont let winners ride. A lot of guys say newbies don't let winners ride..... Well its b/c they havent a clue if it is gonna reverse on them. Having a tried and true system makes letting winners ride very very easy.

Listen, you are still clueless!

advice to you: shut your mouth until your fifth year, before the fifth year, anything you say is garbage.
 
Quote from doublef:

Listen, you are still clueless!

advice to you: shut your mouth until your fifth year, before the fifth year, anything you say is garbage.

Ahhh, children and their immature personal attacks.

If you do not agree with anything I say, I would appreciate a reason rather than just a rude comment. This is a discussion, lets leave it at that please.
 
Quote from wiesman02:

Ahhh, children and their immature personal attacks.

If you do not agree with anything I say, I would appreciate a reason rather than just a rude comment. This is a discussion, lets leave it at that please.

You have a lot of hurdles ahead. Are you open to any input?
 
Instead of bickering, why don't you help each other.

One of the last steps of learning is to teach. I'll be honest, I have only mentored 8 people in my career and those eight have had the want to make it in this business.

When I used to mentor so to speak. I learned new things as well. Those that claim to be GREAT traders, you need to teach...it will help your game.

Those that are new..you shouldn't even be on this site reading this garbage. All the negative words of mess with your head more than you can ever imagine.

Take the time to learn on your own. Find what works for you and run with it.

Since this will surely be my last post on this site...words of advice

1) Understand that its okay to have a losing trade. It is part of the game

2) Have conviction in your trades

3) Don't hesitate

4) Stay disciplined.

NYX
 
Back
Top