Neural Network

What is your experience with Trading using Neural Networks?

  • I think there is something there and still working on it

    Votes: 21 41.2%
  • I lost money and waste time on it

    Votes: 18 35.3%
  • I made money using NN but not worth the risk

    Votes: 1 2.0%
  • I made money consistently using NN and happy with it

    Votes: 11 21.6%

  • Total voters
    51
Quote from bali_survivor:

My late father was an expert in artificial intelligence - Neural Nets, Genetic Programming, Rough sets. He started out witha NN system and eventually that broke down. Then he made a 100% mechanical system and eventually that stopped working. He then devised a discretionary system and that is still working.

In other words: there are no easy shortcuts: you'll have to learn to "read" the markets.

Maria


Would this discretionary system be mostly for "daytrading" or longer term position or swing trading? I think I know the answer..... :)
 
Quote from knifecatcher:

Hi spike,

Is tradingpro NN any good? Do you look at them?

KC

Don't know if they are good. I have had not a single good experience with NN's but it may be due to me and not to the NN's.
Tome it's was a waste of time and money.
 
Hi Jimmi, spike.

I've resumed posting the system trades at my jounal.

I'd like to add something regarding the system I'm trading, tradingpro.com

This system is not NN based. It is a nonlinear dynamics prediction model. As far as I understood, it does have some NN just to choose the best outcome from the model, but the core, the predictive capabilities of the system is not a NN so it should not be compared with other experiencies you could have had with NN.

Dan




Quote from spike500:

If Tradingpro agrees i will post my tradingsignals for a number of days that were published by them.
Just to show what i mean that NN is inferior to human beings. A human being has a huge flexibility to react to an ever changing environment.

Confucius was right: The superior man makes demands on himself, the inferior man makes demands on others.
 
Back
Top